Aaaah! Perhaps you would like to join with me in the “I Hate Plastic Whistles Because They Remind Me of the Recorder that Melted My Brains in Fifth Grade” club. We here at IHPWBTRMRMMBFG will welcome you with open arms (and metal or wooden whistles, of course)
I don’t like them either, I sold my D to a fellow chiffer after it sat around unplayed for over a year and my low A and G I got rid of after only a few months. I don’t know if it was the thick walls or just the fipple design but they sound so boring to me. I play Irish tunes and my personal preference is a whistle with character. The Susatos just sound too pure and bland to me. One of the things I did like about it though was how responsive it was. Ornaments were crisp and clear beyond most other whistles I’ve played, it almost had a piping sound to it; I could easily see how a piper would enjoy it as a practice chanter.
When I see bats flying north from San Diego, now I’ll know where they’re going.
Seriously, we need to talk. Susatos have a large windway, which accounts for the volume if you blow them full tilt straight ahead like, say, a Generation or a Burke. But the large windway also allows room for finessing the embouchure by narrowing the lips and/or blowing at an angle with the whistle “sideways”. They also allow for considerable underblowing while still keeping control. Both techniques can tame the volume, especially in the second octave, and add a lot of complexity to the tone. There’s also an O-ring tweak that can help.
Most things would with that much reverb. In situations like that a Susato would perform well and, as I said, they are very responsive. For me as a player, and as a listener, I don’t much care for the sound of them.
There have been many a time a susato has saved me…like playing for a wedding on a Santa Cruz beach with major gusts of wind…only a susato can cut through something like that. There are some tweaks you can do…just do a little hunting…I’ve seen them around.
I thought I didn’t like susatos when I first started playing either, but they definately have a certain part of the market cornered and I’ve joined there ranks on a few occassions.
I love Lunasa, but I’ve never really liked that song because of the whistle he uses. It’s too harsh for my ears, grating almost. I’m with the IHPWBTRMRMMBFG as far as Susatos are concerned.
There’s just no doubt in my mind that the Susato is the ultimate love-it-or-hate-it whistle. I love them but completely understand how someone would hate 'em.
Your Susato angst (SA) is treatable! However, you must want to be SA-free, and the process requires several steps. Step one: Send me the offending whistle. Step two: I lodge the wild whistle beast in a special Susato stable with my two more docile Susatos (a VSB D and a B). Step three: I play my well-behaved Susatos to provide examples of acceptable behavior for the wild Susato. Step four: I work with the whistle (maybe whispering to it like that horse guy does) until it is broken (you know, like a horse, not as in “damaged”) — this step can take quite a lot of time. Step five: You forget the whistle ever existed and I keep it. —— Result: You are SA-free!