Hmm, I thought the other stuff he finished (at least what I read) sucked. It’s been years ago now, but it was half as good as the stuff J.R.R. completed himself, imo. Did I miss something?
I guess you have to be a real die-hard to really get into his posthumous stuff. A good majority of it is first draft material, and J.R.R. Tolkien was one of those writers who revised the hell out of everything (he even began notes and outlines for a complete rewrite of The Hobbit shortly before he died).
I’m expecting the new book to be very much akin to The Silmarillion.
I would like to be a die-hard fan, but this early stuff was never created with the intent of publishing it, or expanding it to the nth degree, and it shows. As Loren says, its just too difficult to get interested in (for me, at least).
I tried to read the Silmarillion a few times, but I think the only way I could finish it would be if I were getting tested on it. I don’t think J.R.R. ever intended that it be published, but rather kept it as notes upon which to base his far more readable published works. It’s also good to keep in mind that he was a linguist by trade rather than a professional author.
I was pretty hardcore but it did take me a few attempts to make it through the Silmarillion and the same with Unfinished Tales. I’ve made a couple stabs at Lost Tales but that’s the extent of my posthumous Tolkien scholarship. I’m still a fan but have acquired other interests both literary and otherwise. All of the posthumous work is a little hard to read. J.R.R. deftly and methodically folded an immense back-story, as well as an epic story, into the narrative of LotR.
I can see Christopher’s editing and publishing his father’s work in two ways. One is that from all of the biographical information I’ve read his father would absolutely hate that so much of his writing is out there unpolished and unrefined. But two is that Christopher is in a way taking on his father’s mantle in terms of creating a lost English mythology and expanding the Elvish language.
Thank you. I was afraid to be the only one to say that, because then I get…“no! The Silmarillion was, like, total immersion man! You must not be a true believer!”
It was a trudge. Like reading geneologies in the Old Testament.
I’ll wait for the reviews as well.