99p bargain ebay

Hi all,

I really should be in bed, but instead I am fueling my addiction trawling ebay etc, I have loads of work I should of finished hours ago.

anyway same seller as the boosey flute which I think was in E or maybe Eb, the latest one is at 99p , so someone might get a good deal as its a no name flute, I have always wondered why someone would craft a lovely looking flute and not put a name on it.

its a good 4 hours drive from me so I cant test it :smiley:


http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/8-KEYED-LARGE-HOLED-ROSEWOOD-FLUTE-CIRCA-1850-ISH_W0QQitemZ150390504427QQcmdZViewItemQQptZUK_Woodwind_Instruments?hash=item2303f8fbeb

sponge :smiley:

Rather Blackman or Metzler-ish.

Maybe it had to do with flutes that went to the military?
I agree with Annvil, looks a lot like a Blackman or Metzler, at least the keys are the same, probably A. Liddle keys. Looks like the flute may be higher pitched, 450?

I doubt that is the original crown.

Looks like your right anvil, the listings been updated with crown mismatch info,

sponge :smiley:

Guess who told 'em about the crown? I also asked about stamps on keys - none visible, apparently, though buffer cork may be obscuring possible stamp sites… BTW, I don’t think those are Liddle keys - all of his I have seen have the pointed arm attachment to the cup, whereas these have the butt-ended attachment of the key shank to the cup, and are generally a bit chunkier than stamp-identifiable Liddle work - more in the style of “F”, IMO.

I also increasingly doubt the “military” explanation for anonymous flutes - after all, there are plenty of flutes actually stamped with Army identifiers of one sort or another, with or without makers names. There are far too many anonymous flutes for all of them to have been for military use.

Jem, are you saying that I shouldn’t bid big on this one?

Doug, bid as big as you wish! I’m not saying anything - just passing on info/opinion. It doesn’t matter a damn whether the keys are stamped or not save for interest’s sake - it is still a pretty standard amateur’s (what I have been given to understand that Harry Bradley quite soundly terms “English Gentlemens’ flutes”) mid C19th flute - missing its own crown (not a particularly serious issue either value-wise or to replace) but otherwise in decent nick. Who knows how it will play? Some like this are excellent, others OK but nowt special; some are dogs. The ones that look similar which have makers’ names or “AL” stamped keys also vary in playability. It’s a gamble! I reckon there’s a good chance it will prove a decent enough flute, but unlikely one to knock anyone’s socks off, more than which I (or anyone else) really can’t say!