(originly posted in another non-ITM specific C&F forum here)Peter Laban of Co. Clare wrote:........
Also(and that's a general remark that applies to a lot of sites I have looked at over time), almost every time I listen to soundsamples on a maker's website it strikes me as odd that the samples are almost invariably of Irish music played by someone who does not know how to play irish music but plays some heavily tongued, halting style like a converted recorder player not really comfortable with a common way of playing the whistle. Which is all fine but effectively the samples fail to tell me anything useful about the whistles themselves (for example are odd sounding intonations part of the whistle or are they a result of the player's not being too much at home on a whistle). In the past this had led me to not even bother asking about whistles I could otherwise have been interested in. I think a bit more care on this aspect would make the whistles on offer more attractive. (and again this is a general remark, the clips here weren't the worst I heard although they didn't really tell me much I would want to know about a whistle)
I do not mean to be a surrogate moderator here. Just as an act of grass roots charity and proactivism I thought I would start this topic where participants may discuss the soundclips on whistle makers' websites. I thought Peter Laban's quote suitable to start the topic seeing as it is aimed at not ONE website but in general. I do not know what County Clare generals are like but I guess they are the same calibre as generals in other English speaking and English colonised countries as was India in the past .....