I don't see where he claims the artwork as his own. He says he did the work and explains his transfer process quite clearly. He also linked to a previous post where he says he got the designs from your set. Maybe he should've asked permission to do so? In any case, your set is quite possibly on of the most beautiful things I've ever seen. you have done a masterful job. My hat's off to you.gil and julie wrote:Antaine,
With regard to your January 18th posting, in which you state "all the artwork is my own", could you be more specific about your definition of "my own"? I seem to recall that in October of this past year, you posted information about lifting designs from the engraved Lynch set and then applying them to your own.
Is this what you mean by the artwork being your own? In the pictures of the regulators and drones in your recent postings the designs on the brass parts are identical to those on the engraved Lynch set, which just happens to be mine. I don't mind terribly that you pirated my work for your own use, however I take offense to the claim that the artwork is all your own. I spent many hours working out the design for each specific part; they were not taken from a website or a Dover book, but are my own creations and adaptations of existing motifs.
Perhaps you should clarify this for all readers of this forum, and give proper attribution where it is due.
edited:
After scrolling sideways, I see what you're referring to. "artwork on all by yours truly" not "all artwork" I take it back, but I still thinks he does acknowledge your work and does not really try to pass the actual design off as his own. It seems more like a semantic boo-boo.