Metal Whistle - next level up?

[celticmodes]

I've got a friend that's been playing with a low-end whistle for a while and wants to move up. He's not ready for a Burke (i.e. $200 investment) but wants the next step up from the overly chiffy bad 'c' one he's got.

Is there a metal whistle between $50-$100 for an intermediate player?

[Steve Bliven]

Jerry Freeman's tweaked whistles have a great sound and are slightly lower than the range you cite. John Sindt's are great and are slightly above your range.

Best wishes.

Steve

[Feadoggie]

Depends on what you mean by "metal whistle". There are lots of good whistles with metal bodies and plastic in the mouthpiece from Gens, Feadogs to Sindt, Batlett(Syn), etc . Otherwise you looking at Chieftains, Goldies and so on. I just played the Impempe tour whistle recently. That's an all "metal whistle" and it is in the target price range.

Feadoggie

[JTC111]

Not sure what he has on hand right now, but Chuck Tilbury (a poster in this forum) makes some nice aluminum whistles. I have a Bb that I like very much. You might also keep an eye on the used instrument forum as nice whistles show up there pretty often.

[straycat82]

I have a Syn whistle in the key of C that I'd be willing to sell if he likes that key. It has some back pressure that might take getting used to if his current whistle doesn't play that way but it's a nice whistle.

[RonKiley]

The Alba Q1 D sells for about $105 (65GBP). It is a very nice whistle that is a little on the quiet side. It is all aluminium.

Ron

[crookedtune]

The Impempe, from South Africa, is a very good aluminum whistle in your general price range.

There's one on tour that may land in my mailbox today. (Thanks, Pat!)

http://impempewhistles.co.za/5052.html

[Byll]

I would also suggest the Impempe. Ian is truly a stand-up guy, and he makes fine instruments.
If you are interested, please go here: http://impempewhistles.co.za/
Best.
Byll

[ubizmo]

I'm currently selling my Impempe high D, preferring a whistle with a little more back pressure--if indeed "all-metal" is meant.

Ubizmo

[plunk111]

The Impempe, from South Africa, is a very good aluminum whistle in your general price range.

There's one on tour that may land in my mailbox today. (Thanks, Pat!)

http://impempewhistles.co.za/5052.html

Not 'til next week - sorry. I CAN, however, recommend the Impempe whistles (at least the D that I have on tour).

Pat

[celticmodes]

Thanks all.

[scottie]

I just bought a Merlin Silver Excalibur and I am sure it would work for your friend. About five years ago I bought a high d aluminum whistle form Chuck Tilbury who at that time had the company name Granite Falls Manufacturing. The whistle was very well made and sounded awesome. The only problem was me. My wife said I am A.D.D. She is always ribbing me because I try out so many instruments. I can not help it that I like the sounds and want to be an instant player of all these instruments. I ended up selling it because I was not making head way fast enough. I can kick myself now for doing that. I am thinking about contacting him for another whistle to see if he is still in business. I would highly recommend his whistles for anyone. Wish you the best on helping your friend find the right whistle.
Scottie

[JTC111]

I just bought a Merlin Silver Excalibur and I am sure it would work for your friend. About five years ago I bought a high d aluminum whistle form Chuck Tilbury who at that time had the company name Granite Falls Manufacturing. The whistle was very well made and sounded awesome. The only problem was me. My wife said I am A.D.D. She is always ribbing me because I try out so many instruments. I can not help it that I like the sounds and want to be an instant player of all these instruments. I ended up selling it because I was not making head way fast enough. I can kick myself now for doing that. I am thinking about contacting him for another whistle to see if he is still in business. I would highly recommend his whistles for anyone. Wish you the best on helping your friend find the right whistle.
Scottie

Chuck is still in business. I just bought a Bb whistle from him about a month or so ago. I don't know what stock he might still have on hand, but he started this thread a little while back: CP: New batch is ready.
And his website is here: Tilbury Woodwinds Company
FWIW, I like my Tilbury Bb very much.

[scottie]

I just bought a Merlin Silver Excalibur and I am sure it would work for your friend. About five years ago I bought a high d aluminum whistle form Chuck Tilbury who at that time had the company name Granite Falls Manufacturing. The whistle was very well made and sounded awesome. The only problem was me. My wife said I am A.D.D. She is always ribbing me because I try out so many instruments. I can not help it that I like the sounds and want to be an instant player of all these instruments. I ended up selling it because I was not making head way fast enough. I can kick myself now for doing that. I am thinking about contacting him for another whistle to see if he is still in business. I would highly recommend his whistles for anyone. Wish you the best on helping your friend find the right whistle.
Scottie

Chuck is still in business. I just bought a Bb whistle from him about a month or so ago. I don't know what stock he might still have on hand, but he started this thread a little while back: CP: New batch is ready.
And his website is here: Tilbury Woodwinds Company
FWIW, I like my Tilbury Bb very much.

Thanks for the information Jim. I will have to send him a pm. Glad you like your Bb. Do you have many tunes or situations for playing in that key? Have a great day.
Scottie

[JTC111]

Thanks for the information Jim. I will have to send him a pm. Glad you like your Bb. Do you have many tunes or situations for playing in that key? Have a great day.
Scottie

Not many at all, but I like having a variety of keys around. I play them all like they're a D whistle, so finding music in Bb isn't an issue.