Burke vs Chieftain
-
- Posts: 49
- Joined: Wed Aug 16, 2006 12:02 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Northern Florida
Burke vs Chieftain
I'll probably get a lot of different answers on this one, but which would you prefer and why? Is one easier to play than the other? What about the 2d octave? Read somewhere that if that person were to choose between any whistle, it would be the Burke. Don't know where I read it and who said it.
I'm a beginner and am looking for something beyond the Mellow Dog and Susato.
Thanks
Donn
I'm a beginner and am looking for something beyond the Mellow Dog and Susato.
Thanks
Donn
- riverman
- Posts: 692
- Joined: Sun Nov 06, 2005 4:05 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Eel River, Indiana
Congratulations for moving up to a finer whistle! Once you try a custom whistle, you'll never look back! I have never played a Chieftan, but Burkes are sweet, forgiving, moderate in volume, easy in the second octave, unsqueaky, and FINE!
"Whoever comes to me I will never drive away." --Jesus Christ.
- Theo
- Posts: 51
- Joined: Mon Aug 01, 2005 3:24 am
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Enschede, the Netherlands
- Contact:
Whereas Chieftains take loads of air, are unforgiving and are very loud. They make you nearly pass out trying to hit the high B. But the low Chieftains have that Cosmic Drainpipe effect, which is something my Burke doesn't have. The high ones have a richness of tone as well.riverman wrote:Congratulations for moving up to a finer whistle! Once you try a custom whistle, you'll never look back! I have never played a Chieftan, but Burkes are sweet, forgiving, moderate in volume, easy in the second octave, unsqueaky, and FINE!
So, in short, it depends a lot on what you're looking for in a whistle! I'd say: Chieftains: loud and rich, Burke: moderately loud and very pure.
- jkrazy52
- Posts: 772
- Joined: Tue Apr 06, 2004 1:12 am
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Southern Ohio
Donn, you probably will get a lot of opinions. The only real way to tell which you prefer is to try them. I've played a couple of Chieftains, and a couple of Burkes. IMO (in my opinion), Burkes are a lot easier to play, particlarly in the 2nd octave, as a beginner. On the other hand, a Chieftain, in the right player's hands, will play beautifully. I was told, as a beginner, that Overtons & Chieftains were designed more for "power" players. It's been true in my experience.
A couple of other choices for possible whistles to try ... Dixon & Alba. Dixon was my "next whistle beyond" ... and it's still one of my favorites. Alba has it's own personality (much like it's maker), and another of my favorites.
Judy
A couple of other choices for possible whistles to try ... Dixon & Alba. Dixon was my "next whistle beyond" ... and it's still one of my favorites. Alba has it's own personality (much like it's maker), and another of my favorites.
Judy
- StewySmoot
- Posts: 735
- Joined: Mon Jul 02, 2001 6:00 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: NYC
I preferred a Chieftain simply because it was more fun to play, meaning it boils down to personal preference.
I just went thru the scales on all my Low Ds and the upper octave on the Chieftain is not difficult at all. High B (and above) seems linear to the rest of the notes below it.
I just went thru the scales on all my Low Ds and the upper octave on the Chieftain is not difficult at all. High B (and above) seems linear to the rest of the notes below it.
<a href="http://www.whistletotheworld.com/" target="_blank"> Whistle to the World</a>
Helping underprivileged kids learn music via the Irish Whistle.
Helping underprivileged kids learn music via the Irish Whistle.
- PhilO
- Posts: 2931
- Joined: Wed Jun 27, 2001 6:00 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: New York
I was surprised when I saw that particular pairing to choose from - they are im most ways at the opposite ends of the whistle playing spectrum. Most people I think wind up playing consistently one "type" or the other. However, most people also have probably experimented with both through the years. I've played both over the years and once had a full set of Overtons (which I'd put in the general Chieftain type) and then sold them off (only to recently acquire a high D for the collection). I prefer Burkes, Abells, Copelands, Reyburns, Busmans, O'Riordans, Humphreys, Black Diamonds, Sindts...you see there are lots to choose from.
As to the Burke - a wonderful jump to a better class of whistle. My Burke black tip brass D remains over the past 2 years my work horse whistle.
Get one...then another....then another....WHOA is you brother.
Philo
As to the Burke - a wonderful jump to a better class of whistle. My Burke black tip brass D remains over the past 2 years my work horse whistle.
Get one...then another....then another....WHOA is you brother.
Philo
"This is this; this ain't something else. This is this." - Robert DeNiro, "The Deer Hunter," 1978.
- dwinterfield
- Posts: 1768
- Joined: Mon Jul 19, 2004 5:46 am
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Boston
I'm a dedicated Burke player, so I'm biased. A year or two back, I bought an alleged Chieftain E flat off e-bay. Not a very good whistle and not fun to play. In fact it's so bad I've often suspected it may be a knock-off. I just went to the Chieftain web site and it shows where I might find some initials. I'll look when I get home tonight. I guess the moral of my story is that one should buy directly from the maker, if possible. If not, stick with reputable dealers. Be very, very careful of high-end used whistles. I gather from this site that counterfits have been a particular problem for Chietain and Overton.
Having looked at Phil's web site, I have suggestions for him and others selling on the web. 1) Please provide several close-up, non-artistic photos of each whistle or other product. 2) Provide unadorned sound clips. On at least two occasions I've made and internet purchase based on sound clips. By that I mean 2 sellers provided clips and 6 didn't. The 6 who didn't, didn't make the final cut. 3) Provide a way to disable the flash player stuff.
Having looked at Phil's web site, I have suggestions for him and others selling on the web. 1) Please provide several close-up, non-artistic photos of each whistle or other product. 2) Provide unadorned sound clips. On at least two occasions I've made and internet purchase based on sound clips. By that I mean 2 sellers provided clips and 6 didn't. The 6 who didn't, didn't make the final cut. 3) Provide a way to disable the flash player stuff.
- Unseen122
- Posts: 3542
- Joined: Tue May 04, 2004 7:21 pm
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Tell us something.: Of course I'm not a bot; I've been here for years... Apparently that isn't enough to pass muster though!
- Location: Los Angeles, CA
- Contact:
I actually just made this decision for a new Bb. I needed one that was not too expensive, loud enough to play in a Jazz Ensemble, and tonally good. I was originally thinking the Cheiftian, but I tend to clog those really easily.
Yes, the sound is different. A Burke is sweet and purer, less wind noise and less texture to the tone. Burkes also take way less push in the upper octave. Cheiftians are a very powerful Whistle in the high range, I have never been a fan of the higher ones. The tone is rough, textured, multi tonal, more nasal, and brighter. Noticing that you play Susatos a Cheiftian won't be hard to manage if you are used to those. If you are used to the Mellow Dog, a Burke is probably the way to go. I used to have a DASBT, which was not really my cup of tea. Too pure, it sounded sterile. The Brass Burkes I have played have all amazed me. I have never played his composite models. My recommendation if you like the Burke relm is to go with the DBSBT. Of course if you like power and value a rought textured tone, the Cheiftian is the way to go.
I ended up going with the Burke Bb Brass, it arrived yesterday right in time for practice. I am super happy with it. Not sterile like the DASBT, not commanding like a Cheiftian. Some hints of Chiff here and there. A low register that can be leaned into. Visually appealing. Loud enough, but it will never hurt my ears. Sweet pure tone with the warmth and texture of Brass. It can be played with more edge. Seriously close to being perfect, it goes at the top of my list next to a Sindt C, Busman Olivewood D, and Sweetheart Pro D.
All in all the desicion is up to you, I have given you what I think should help you make your decision. Please, don't think because I am so pleased with my Burke Bb that you will be pleased as pleased with the same whistle.
Yes, the sound is different. A Burke is sweet and purer, less wind noise and less texture to the tone. Burkes also take way less push in the upper octave. Cheiftians are a very powerful Whistle in the high range, I have never been a fan of the higher ones. The tone is rough, textured, multi tonal, more nasal, and brighter. Noticing that you play Susatos a Cheiftian won't be hard to manage if you are used to those. If you are used to the Mellow Dog, a Burke is probably the way to go. I used to have a DASBT, which was not really my cup of tea. Too pure, it sounded sterile. The Brass Burkes I have played have all amazed me. I have never played his composite models. My recommendation if you like the Burke relm is to go with the DBSBT. Of course if you like power and value a rought textured tone, the Cheiftian is the way to go.
I ended up going with the Burke Bb Brass, it arrived yesterday right in time for practice. I am super happy with it. Not sterile like the DASBT, not commanding like a Cheiftian. Some hints of Chiff here and there. A low register that can be leaned into. Visually appealing. Loud enough, but it will never hurt my ears. Sweet pure tone with the warmth and texture of Brass. It can be played with more edge. Seriously close to being perfect, it goes at the top of my list next to a Sindt C, Busman Olivewood D, and Sweetheart Pro D.
All in all the desicion is up to you, I have given you what I think should help you make your decision. Please, don't think because I am so pleased with my Burke Bb that you will be pleased as pleased with the same whistle.
- Whitmores75087
- Posts: 798
- Joined: Tue Jul 09, 2002 6:00 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Dundalk, Ireland (now living in TX)
- Contact:
-
- Posts: 49
- Joined: Wed Aug 16, 2006 12:02 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Northern Florida
Burke or Chieftain
Thanks everyone for your comments about the Burke and Chieftain. I was leaning towards the Burke from the reviews I read. Get both? I'm not that rich! Even the Burke is a little steep for me right now. Maybe I can find one that someone wants to get rid of. But from what you say about it, that's not likely.
Again, thanks all especially Judy, Phil and Rini. Your comments well taken.
Donn
Again, thanks all especially Judy, Phil and Rini. Your comments well taken.
Donn