Most people seem agreed that Sindt's sound like good Generations. I've never met a good Generation in the flesh. I take it everyone agrees that Sindt's have quite a bit of attack chiff. So the disagreement had to be about the purity of tone of the post-attack sound. Most people seemed to class Sindts as impure; Dale and Jessie notably disagreed firmly.
I've had a Sindt A/Bb set for a while and found the sound cloudy. I'd call that impure and I have done from time to time. A few days ago I received a Sindt D. I got a surprise. Although it was recognisably akin to the A/Bb whistle set, the features that made for cloudiness in that set did not make for anything like that in the D. In short, I found the post-attack tone to be quite pure.
Conclusion: if my whistles are typical the higher Sindts are pure, the lower Sindts are cloudy. Those who think of the higher whistles as impure must have in mind their very noticeable attack chiff.
Oh come on now. Surely we can't reach agreement on this issue can we?
