The Dubliners... your opinion
The Dubliners... your opinion
So, I was at session tonight, when one of the guys spoke dismissively of The Dubliners. I'm not one to get offended by differing opinions, but the guy spoke of it as if it wasn't "real" Irish music. Granted, it's not "traditional" music like what we do at sessions (usually), but I think it's legitimate Irish folk music. His tone almost seemed to suggest they were nothing more than Posers.
What do you think? Agree? Disagree?
The very nature of the question made me unsure of the correct forum for this...
I can only guess what the reaction might have been had I mentioned my fondness for Flogging Molly.
What do you think? Agree? Disagree?
The very nature of the question made me unsure of the correct forum for this...
I can only guess what the reaction might have been had I mentioned my fondness for Flogging Molly.
Let me be the first to disagree.
Words like 'influential' and 'ground-breaking' spring to mind. These guys were at the forefront of the 60's folk revival and brought Irish folk and ITM to a new audience. Their music has stood the test of time for 45 years. They were (and are) excellent musicians: Luke Kelly, John Sheahan, Barney McKenna, Ronnie Drew to name a few ......Legendary musicians.
Whether you like their music or not, nobody can question the extent of their influence.
Words like 'influential' and 'ground-breaking' spring to mind. These guys were at the forefront of the 60's folk revival and brought Irish folk and ITM to a new audience. Their music has stood the test of time for 45 years. They were (and are) excellent musicians: Luke Kelly, John Sheahan, Barney McKenna, Ronnie Drew to name a few ......Legendary musicians.
Whether you like their music or not, nobody can question the extent of their influence.
- Innocent Bystander
- Posts: 6816
- Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2005 12:51 pm
- antispam: No
- Location: Directly above the centre of the Earth (UK)
I hear this kind of thing too. Partly it's because they have popular appeal and so are not "select" enough. (Too influential.) Partly because they've been around so long that people regard them as the "establishment". (Too influential!)
Some folk will never be happy with popularisers.
Some folk will never be happy with popularisers.
Wizard needs whiskey, badly!
-
- Posts: 132
- Joined: Thu Jan 02, 2003 6:00 pm
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Tell us something.: I am a flute player. I play ITM pretty much exclusively. Like to browse and occasionally post on flute related discussions
- Location: Toronto
Bands like the Dubliners clearly cannot be classed as traditional because:
1)a good portion of their repetoire is of non-irish origin or of known authorship,
2)the songs that are traditional often only date from around the mid 19th century, and
3)The instrumentation (e.g. guitars) and arrangements are heavily influenced by the American 60’s folk revival.
But wait a minute…. how does this differ from 90% of what one hears played by instrumental ITM groups or in sessions these days?
Perhaps the real distinguishing feature between the ballad and instrumental traditions is that songs tend to have a greater appeal amongst the general (non-musician) population. This causes some snobby “tune purists” to look down their noses at ballads, as well as spawning a lot of cheesy second-rate imitators of good legitimate balladeers such as the Dubliners.
1)a good portion of their repetoire is of non-irish origin or of known authorship,
2)the songs that are traditional often only date from around the mid 19th century, and
3)The instrumentation (e.g. guitars) and arrangements are heavily influenced by the American 60’s folk revival.
But wait a minute…. how does this differ from 90% of what one hears played by instrumental ITM groups or in sessions these days?
Perhaps the real distinguishing feature between the ballad and instrumental traditions is that songs tend to have a greater appeal amongst the general (non-musician) population. This causes some snobby “tune purists” to look down their noses at ballads, as well as spawning a lot of cheesy second-rate imitators of good legitimate balladeers such as the Dubliners.
- djm
- Posts: 17853
- Joined: Sat May 31, 2003 5:47 am
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Canadia
- Contact:
The Dubliners picked up when the Irish learned that the Clancy Bros were getting famous in the US playing all this old stuff; riding their coattails, as it were. They played what was popular. They were rough and dirty and famous for their drunkeness. The Irish loved them.
I think it's an acquired taste. Some people even like the Pogues.
djm
I think it's an acquired taste. Some people even like the Pogues.
djm
I'd rather be atop the foothills than beneath them.
I think their choice of singers after Luke Kelly and Ronny Drew has been awful.
Paddy Reilly and Patsy Watchorn et al are too Foster and Allen.
They kick the life out of songs that Luke Kelly breathed so much into.
Then again, who could replace Luke Kelly?
Mukade
Paddy Reilly and Patsy Watchorn et al are too Foster and Allen.
They kick the life out of songs that Luke Kelly breathed so much into.
Then again, who could replace Luke Kelly?
Mukade
'The people who play the flat pipes usually have more peace of mind. I like that.'
- Tony Mcmahon
- Tony Mcmahon
-
- Posts: 132
- Joined: Thu Jan 02, 2003 6:00 pm
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Tell us something.: I am a flute player. I play ITM pretty much exclusively. Like to browse and occasionally post on flute related discussions
- Location: Toronto
Sadly, they are not widely considered a real Irish folk band as they made the mistake of becoming widely popular amongst real Irish folk.They played what was popular. They were rough and dirty and famous for their drunkeness. The Irish loved them.
I think it's an acquired taste. Some people even like the Pogues.
A while back, I saw on YouTube excerpts from a documentary on the Dubliners which I think originally aired on Irish TV. It had interviews with a number of respected figures in Irish trad/folk music who praised the Dubliners and acknowledged their influence on Irish music. To each his own of course. One may not care for their style of music. But to cast them as "posers" or to lump them in with some later "celtic-rock" bands is not really fair IMHO.
regards,
SteveB
-
- Posts: 29
- Joined: Mon Oct 01, 2007 10:06 am
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Iowa
folk music changes and evolves, thats the nature of it. thats why I think the term ITM is kinda funny, what is considered ITM now was considered new and not traditional a couple decades ago. why would you want to play the same songs over and over whithout ever doing anything original anyway? someone made up the songs in the first place. original music in the irish-folk vein is great. it preseves irish roots and brings it to a new generation. I love the dubliners, the pogues, and the tosesers and such like. (although I do despise celtic "world" music, but I think that has more to do with the crappyness and the bourgeoisness of it. and the meaninglessness of it)
It is a travesty to suggest that the Clancys ever wore coattails or any garment other than the aran sweaters in which they were born.djm wrote:The Dubliners picked up when the Irish learned that the Clancy Bros were getting famous in the US playing all this old stuff; riding their coattails...
But yeah I see where you are going: Luke Kelly singing 'Scorn Not His Simplicity'; Shane McGowan singing 'A Pair Of Brown Eyes'. Acquired tastes indeed. Not music for the pop fan.
- SteveShaw
- Posts: 10049
- Joined: Mon Mar 17, 2003 4:24 am
- antispam: No
- Location: Beautiful, beautiful north Cornwall. The Doom Bar is on me.
- Contact:
I love the Dubliners. But I tend to copy only the tracks that Luke sings on, except for two or three with Ronnie Drew. Luke was (is) my favourite Irish singer by a long chalk and I think the Dubs, on their day, were the best vehicle for his wonderful voice. Opinions, opinions!
"Last night, among his fellow roughs,
He jested, quaff'd and swore."
They cut me down and I leapt up high
I am the life that'll never, never die.
I'll live in you if you'll live in me -
I am the lord of the dance, said he!
He jested, quaff'd and swore."
They cut me down and I leapt up high
I am the life that'll never, never die.
I'll live in you if you'll live in me -
I am the lord of the dance, said he!
Well I got to say I love them dearly, they may not be traditional as some may have it, but I can't help but grin at most of there songs. Here in the states though I guess it can be complicated as to what people consider to be real Irish music. You turn on any folk band that sings a Irish tune and many people will feel it is as Irish as it gets. To others more involved in the music they consider it just a attempt to ride the coatail of a music style...
In the end we all see things diffrent, but my vote is they are Irish music and they are not half bad at all...
In the end we all see things diffrent, but my vote is they are Irish music and they are not half bad at all...
But since it falls unto my lot that I should go and you should not, I'll gently rise and softly call, goodnight and joy be with you all.
- s1m0n
- Posts: 10069
- Joined: Wed Oct 06, 2004 12:17 am
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 10
- Location: The Inside Passage
Re: The Dubliners... your opinion
Any one of them could play him under the table, as traditional as you please.Thomaston wrote:So, I was at session tonight, when one of the guys spoke dismissively of The Dubliners. I'm not one to get offended by differing opinions, but the guy spoke of it as if it wasn't "real" Irish music.
And now there was no doubt that the trees were really moving - moving in and out through one another as if in a complicated country dance. ('And I suppose,' thought Lucy, 'when trees dance, it must be a very, very country dance indeed.')
C.S. Lewis
C.S. Lewis
- dwinterfield
- Posts: 1768
- Joined: Mon Jul 19, 2004 5:46 am
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Boston
As it happens I've been listening to the "Dubliners at Their Best" cd lately. It's wonderful stuff, all early I suspect. There are at least 5 or 6 instrumental that sound remarkably like traditional jigs and reels. Being in the US in the 60s, I only knew the Clancys and liked them well enough. A few years back, I heard someone say that the Clancys cleaned up their act, put on white sweaters and became tv stars in America - the Dubliners stayed in the pubs.
- Daleth
- Posts: 49
- Joined: Fri Jun 09, 2006 2:55 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Seattle, WA
I like when people pretend they're the trad police. Personally, I look at it this way. In 100 years, people will probably still remember the Dubliners and their music will still be played. Will anybody remember that guy who thinks they're not traditional, or play music because he played it? Traditions aren't made by stodgy traditionalists who thinks tradition is something that doesn't ever change and shouldn't ever be allowed to.