How many tunes once had lyrics?
Posted: Wed Jun 24, 2020 11:13 am
I've been teaching myself "I buried my wife and danced on top of her," which title I dislike very much although it's a great tune. O'Neill writes about it in a somewhat confusing way:
"One of Delaney's best jigs was the "Frieze Breeches," which in some form is known all throughout Munster. A strain remembered from my mother's singing of it was added to Delaney's version, making a total of six in our printed setting. A ridiculous, although typical, folksong, called "I Buried My Wife and Danced on Top of Her," used to be sung to this air, which bears a close resemblance to our version of "O'Gallagher's Frolics."
The tune is very similar to versions of "the Frieze Britches" that I've heard but not that similar to the version in O'Neill, but neither is "O'Gallagher's frolics."
I might make up my own name for it.
But O'Neill mentions a song to this air--you can certainly see how the title would scan with the notes in the A part in English. You can certainly see how the tune with those lyrics might be some Irishman's inebriated party piece, and certainly O'Neill would want no part of such undignified fun-having. Now and again I see other tunes that seem to have had lyrics in the past. How common is this? I which came first, the tune or the lyrics? I'm thinking the tune.
"One of Delaney's best jigs was the "Frieze Breeches," which in some form is known all throughout Munster. A strain remembered from my mother's singing of it was added to Delaney's version, making a total of six in our printed setting. A ridiculous, although typical, folksong, called "I Buried My Wife and Danced on Top of Her," used to be sung to this air, which bears a close resemblance to our version of "O'Gallagher's Frolics."
The tune is very similar to versions of "the Frieze Britches" that I've heard but not that similar to the version in O'Neill, but neither is "O'Gallagher's frolics."
I might make up my own name for it.
But O'Neill mentions a song to this air--you can certainly see how the title would scan with the notes in the A part in English. You can certainly see how the tune with those lyrics might be some Irishman's inebriated party piece, and certainly O'Neill would want no part of such undignified fun-having. Now and again I see other tunes that seem to have had lyrics in the past. How common is this? I which came first, the tune or the lyrics? I'm thinking the tune.