Recommended inexpensive flutes

[chicagopsych]

I know this topic has been mentioned several times, but I just want to make sure that I have reviewed what is out there. When people request advice for an inexpensive (i.e. "just wanting to to try it out") flute the common responses are: Hamilton Practice flute, Garry Somer's Aluminum flute, and, Doug Tipple's PVC flute, all of which can be had for $150 or less. Less recommended are the polymer Dixons. Every other recommendation is more than double those at $400 or higher. So am I missing any maker or model when it comes to recommended flutes under $200 or even under $300? Is it just those three?

Thanks!

[Sirchronique]

Better off saving up for longer and getting one of the $400-$800 flutes as a starter. That being said, Patrick Olwell makes bamboo flutes that can sometimes be had for less that 400, and they are really quite nice.

[chicagopsych]

Thanks for the reply. I should add that affordability is not really an issue. In theory I could afford most. However, I will be getting the flute just to have have fun on. It will never likely be a primary instrument that I play, but I like playing instruments for stress management and want to try the flute, as those that require breath control are especially relaxing. From what I have read and heard (sound samples), I feel confident that the three I have mentioned will suit my needs, but I wanted to make sure that I have not missed any worth considering in that price range. Thanks again

[dubrosa22]

There's the polymer or wood M&E flute too.
And give Angus Fifes a go too. Davy offers lots of conical flutes as well as Fifes in some beautiful woods and also aluminium cylindrical flutes. Worth investigating.

V

[dunnp]

The Sweet Shannon comes in at 275 last I checked.
The antique market being what it is now if you have patience and don't mind a fixer upper
you can find exceptional flutes for nothing.
I bought a fine French flute for 30 pounds , an excellent Huller flute for 100 pounds, and an English large holes Metzler type for 100 pounds all in the last year.

[chicagopsych]

Thanks for the Shannon reminder. That flute seems to occupy a space by its self regarding price and quality. I have seen the Angus flutes. Great prices and looks, but I have not read anyone's views on his flutes, just the fifes. I have read a lot about the M&E flutes. I know they are more expensive, but not by much. However, their website does not work, so I have never been able to investigate or inquire about them.

[jim stone]

I've played the Shannon and consider it impressively good.

[deisman]

I recommend Gary Somers Rudall model. I have owned flutes costing 3-5X as much in wood and for me the Somers stands up to the comparison. Your mileage may vary.

[Jayhawk]

If you want sub $300...the Shannon is impossible to beat in my experience. Just a good, basic flute.

Eric