busterbill wrote:
It's the old played in wood.
Yes indeed. Guitarists could carry on for months, if not years, about how steel-string boxes get better with age. Vintage appeal is also a factor; there are even companies producing replicas of pre-war Martins, complete with dishonest wear. Lack of supply, lack of musicians' ability to pony up, or both feed that market.
I also have somewhat mixed feelings about the guitar, but for different reasons. One is the huge price gap between beginner/beater models and what I consider the starting point of high-end models. (Compared to whistles, the increase in percentage might not be much, but the increase in price is
huge.) Another is the need to periodically change strings (believe me, I'm horrible at that) and picks. But the biggest strike against the guitar, for me, is storing one. Too bulky and too difficult to keep out of the way of the pets!
By the way, I've heard that altered tuning is favored for guitars in ITM. I believe DADGAD is preferred, but standard EADGAE isn't used as frequently.