Recommended tweaked whistle in the freeman price bracket?
Posted: Sun Jun 28, 2020 1:44 am
I have been reading around here the last couple of days and see there is quite a lot on offer.
As I have read more I have got a better idea of what each offering does.
The ones I have read about are mainly tjpotterwhistles (though I have not read anything on how they play, there are sounds on his website but I would like to know how it plays in terms of sensitivity etc) but the main two others being freeman of course and the cillian o briain.
I have bought about 3 cheap whistles and just want to buy one that does not shriek on second octave. I don't really want increased sensitivity. I tried some 'homebrew' tweaks on these like putting some tack in the mouthpiece as I was told it will shorten the gap between the octaves but I didn't really like that. I don't have problems with the 'handling' of the stock ones just the awful cacophony they tend to make.
I will note that I own a polymer dixon dx004 which sounds very clean on both octaves and plays well so it is not just an issue of me not being able to handle any whistle. It is my best whistle I have at the moment but I am not totally satisfied with the 'plastic' sound it makes which I feel is more akin to a recorder and am looking for an equivalent price point tin whistle to have the more authentic old school sound. As I was happy with the build of the dixon I was thinking about one of their brass whistles but sadly they have discontinued making them. I asked them why and they told me they can't get the material any more for a good price. I find that hard to believe since all other makers are having no such shortage. Anyway, for whatever reason they have stopped doing them but I am quite intrigued by tweaked offerings now anyway.
One thing I hadn't thought about is the sensitivity issue. I imagine I would get used to it if a tweaked whistle had that increased sensitivity but it certainly wasn't something I looked for or wanted. The cillian o briain was at the front of my list until I started reading how sensitive it is. I was really just looking for a cleaned up faedog or generation, ie basic tweaks to remove the rough edges, not a completely new sound; from what I read the cillian o briain improved is the latter case.
I heard a sound clip on one of the threads on here from some years ago of a freeman tweaked faedog a member had reviewed and freeman himself replied in the thread saying he made very minor adjustments in the vein I was discussing above, aiming to keep the 'meaty' sound, they referred to it as 'reedy', of the stock generation while just getting rid of the nasty edges they most times come with.
I would prefer that but faedogs are not on offer of the ones he sells are they now? Also I read he is very busy right now due to helping out with the current crisis. I don't mind waiting a couple of months til he is but even when he is fully focused back on tweaking I don't think he even sells anything like that now? He hasn't sold faedogs for some years that I can tell? and I read he stopped tweaking the generations due to lack of consistency in the stock product and what he does still sell seems more of the sweeter end 'full revamp' type of tweaked similar to the o briains, is that right?
If those are all that are on offer now I might as well just take my pick from either his or o briaians' and there is a shop I found that has o briains ones in stock I might just go with his, even though it slightly more expensive.
But yea I would have preferred just a cleaned up stock sounding faedog/generation rather than completely rebuilt sound so wondering if you guys knew of one which might more fit the bill in this same price bracket (so not looking into the upper killarney type class)? There seem to be a couple of smaller named tweakers I saw mentioned in passing but didn't read anything about how they sound so maybe you guys, with much larger knowledge of what is on offer, could advise better?
So to sum up, a classic faedog/generation type base whistle/sound with the price bracket of a freeman with just the rough edges cleaned up to simply be in tune and easily play clean notes on both the 1st and second octave.
As I have read more I have got a better idea of what each offering does.
The ones I have read about are mainly tjpotterwhistles (though I have not read anything on how they play, there are sounds on his website but I would like to know how it plays in terms of sensitivity etc) but the main two others being freeman of course and the cillian o briain.
I have bought about 3 cheap whistles and just want to buy one that does not shriek on second octave. I don't really want increased sensitivity. I tried some 'homebrew' tweaks on these like putting some tack in the mouthpiece as I was told it will shorten the gap between the octaves but I didn't really like that. I don't have problems with the 'handling' of the stock ones just the awful cacophony they tend to make.
I will note that I own a polymer dixon dx004 which sounds very clean on both octaves and plays well so it is not just an issue of me not being able to handle any whistle. It is my best whistle I have at the moment but I am not totally satisfied with the 'plastic' sound it makes which I feel is more akin to a recorder and am looking for an equivalent price point tin whistle to have the more authentic old school sound. As I was happy with the build of the dixon I was thinking about one of their brass whistles but sadly they have discontinued making them. I asked them why and they told me they can't get the material any more for a good price. I find that hard to believe since all other makers are having no such shortage. Anyway, for whatever reason they have stopped doing them but I am quite intrigued by tweaked offerings now anyway.
One thing I hadn't thought about is the sensitivity issue. I imagine I would get used to it if a tweaked whistle had that increased sensitivity but it certainly wasn't something I looked for or wanted. The cillian o briain was at the front of my list until I started reading how sensitive it is. I was really just looking for a cleaned up faedog or generation, ie basic tweaks to remove the rough edges, not a completely new sound; from what I read the cillian o briain improved is the latter case.
I heard a sound clip on one of the threads on here from some years ago of a freeman tweaked faedog a member had reviewed and freeman himself replied in the thread saying he made very minor adjustments in the vein I was discussing above, aiming to keep the 'meaty' sound, they referred to it as 'reedy', of the stock generation while just getting rid of the nasty edges they most times come with.
I would prefer that but faedogs are not on offer of the ones he sells are they now? Also I read he is very busy right now due to helping out with the current crisis. I don't mind waiting a couple of months til he is but even when he is fully focused back on tweaking I don't think he even sells anything like that now? He hasn't sold faedogs for some years that I can tell? and I read he stopped tweaking the generations due to lack of consistency in the stock product and what he does still sell seems more of the sweeter end 'full revamp' type of tweaked similar to the o briains, is that right?
If those are all that are on offer now I might as well just take my pick from either his or o briaians' and there is a shop I found that has o briains ones in stock I might just go with his, even though it slightly more expensive.
But yea I would have preferred just a cleaned up stock sounding faedog/generation rather than completely rebuilt sound so wondering if you guys knew of one which might more fit the bill in this same price bracket (so not looking into the upper killarney type class)? There seem to be a couple of smaller named tweakers I saw mentioned in passing but didn't read anything about how they sound so maybe you guys, with much larger knowledge of what is on offer, could advise better?
So to sum up, a classic faedog/generation type base whistle/sound with the price bracket of a freeman with just the rough edges cleaned up to simply be in tune and easily play clean notes on both the 1st and second octave.