Mary Bergin, please.If you were to have the choice of sitting in a small venue and listening to someone play in session, would you prefer listening to Jane and John Doe, competent whistlers, or a superstar of the Mary Bergin or Joannie Madden variety?
Listening and Learning
- Jens_Hoppe
- Posts: 1166
- Joined: Tue Jun 26, 2001 6:00 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
Sweetone you have an approach typical for a classical musician. What she said was she doesn't like over produced overpolished music. She didn't say liked mediocre music.
This music can be played well and very well with letting the technology of the recording studio take over, the best recording are pften those of players sitting at home in their kitchen playing away.
A solo fiddle recording like Bobby Casey's Taking Flight [or the 'home'recordings on Casey in the Cowhouse], are the best you can get[just to put a name to some], I wouldn't be able to think of any fiddle player able to surpass that music, yet it's just the man and his fiddle enjoying a tune.
As a more recent example you should listen to Kevin Crehan's CD, just the fiddle and very well thought out but no production to get in the way, plain good traditional music. That's what we are talking about here.
This music can be played well and very well with letting the technology of the recording studio take over, the best recording are pften those of players sitting at home in their kitchen playing away.
A solo fiddle recording like Bobby Casey's Taking Flight [or the 'home'recordings on Casey in the Cowhouse], are the best you can get[just to put a name to some], I wouldn't be able to think of any fiddle player able to surpass that music, yet it's just the man and his fiddle enjoying a tune.
As a more recent example you should listen to Kevin Crehan's CD, just the fiddle and very well thought out but no production to get in the way, plain good traditional music. That's what we are talking about here.
-
- Posts: 156
- Joined: Tue Oct 08, 2002 6:00 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
I agree with Wombat. There's more than one way to enjoy music and sometimes the participational enjoyment and the enjoyment of a performance can be mutually exclusive. But there's nothing wrong with that. Trying to keep up in a session of amazing players could be more frustrating than worthwhile--better to just sit back and take it in. In the same way sometimes I imagine symphonies aren't much fun for the percussionist or the french horn: at least not the same kind of fun as for me in the fourth row.
Also perhaps worth remembering that great teachers and great musicians are not always the same people, and great lessons and great sessions not the same events.
Also perhaps worth remembering that great teachers and great musicians are not always the same people, and great lessons and great sessions not the same events.
- Isilwen
- Posts: 944
- Joined: Sat Mar 09, 2002 6:00 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: In the Mountains to the West...
In response to the first posting in this thread:
Personally I'd prefer either or. If these particular "whistlers off the street" were quite competent in their skill, then I wouldn't mind learning from them. I also wouldn't mind the opportunity to get to play with a competent "star whistler."
I just like the music, and if it's good music, then it's even better!
Personally I'd prefer either or. If these particular "whistlers off the street" were quite competent in their skill, then I wouldn't mind learning from them. I also wouldn't mind the opportunity to get to play with a competent "star whistler."
I just like the music, and if it's good music, then it's even better!
Light spills into the hidden valley,
Illuminating the falls, paths, and
The breathtaking Elvish dwelling
Set back among great trees.
Lilting strains of Elven songs fill my heart;
I am finally home. ~Isilwen Elanessë
Illuminating the falls, paths, and
The breathtaking Elvish dwelling
Set back among great trees.
Lilting strains of Elven songs fill my heart;
I am finally home. ~Isilwen Elanessë
- colomon
- Posts: 2140
- Joined: Thu Aug 30, 2001 6:00 pm
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Tell us something.: Whistle player, aspiring C#/D accordion and flute player, and aspiring tunesmith. Particularly interested in the music of South Sligo and Newfoundland. Inspired by the music of Peter Horan, Fred Finn, Rufus Guinchard, Emile Benoit, and Liz Carroll.
I've got some compositions up at http://www.harmonyware.com/tunes/SolsTunes.html - Location: Midland, Michigan
- Contact:
While it's certainly possible (heck, common) to have a lesson which is not a session, I'd argue that any great session is also a great lesson. Seeing how great players handle themselves -- what tunes they play, how they play them, the swing and the feel and the little variations you've never heard before -- that's utterly invaluable. It's the purest form of a lesson.On 2002-10-22 09:23, Michael Sullivan wrote:
...and great lessons and great sessions not the same events.
Which isn't to say that it's necessarily a lesson the student is ready for. I mean, I learned a lot at those sessions with Peter Horan last year, but I wasn't really ready for them yet. I would have learned so much more if they'd happened to me now. (Tenses get confused there, but you know what I mean.)
- energy
- Posts: 418
- Joined: Tue Sep 04, 2001 6:00 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: The middle of a corn field...
Hold on, folks! Are you hearing what you're saying? Here's the situation: Two sessions in your town tonight: One is frequented by the regulars in your area, excellent amatuers who show good muscianship, and the other is gonna be a bunch of world-class professionals who music is simply incomprehensible at times; you're going to go the session with the less immaculate players just because you can learn more!?! I'm incredulous...when you've got a chance to hear players at that level in an informal level, who cares if you can't learn a thing?? Go for the music!!! The music would be its own reward... I can't believe that any of you faced with this situation would really go to the session with the less talented musicians. Even on a weekly basis.
The real issue for me is which of the musicians play with more feeling. Just because the technique is better doesn't mean you're a better musician.
_________________
True Believer
Nate
<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: energy on 2002-10-22 12:23 ]</font>
The real issue for me is which of the musicians play with more feeling. Just because the technique is better doesn't mean you're a better musician.
_________________
True Believer
Nate
<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: energy on 2002-10-22 12:23 ]</font>
- sweetone
- Posts: 175
- Joined: Tue Jun 18, 2002 6:00 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Belgium
On the Kerry Whistle site you can see and listen to life recordings of several well know Irish musicians and groups as Lunasa, Flook, Mike McGoldrick, Phil Hardy himself etc. They are playing live, no studio involved, nothing overproduced, just plain music but played with absolute virtuosity. This got nothing to do with the fact I'm a classical musician as well, just like music at its best.On 2002-10-22 04:55, Peter Laban wrote:
Sweetone you have an approach typical for a classical musician. What she said was she doesn't like over produced overpolished music. She didn't say liked mediocre music.
This music can be played well and very well with letting the technology of the recording studio take over, the best recording are pften those of players sitting at home in their kitchen playing away.
A solo fiddle recording like Bobby Casey's Taking Flight [or the 'home'recordings on Casey in the Cowhouse], are the best you can get[just to put a name to some], I wouldn't be able to think of any fiddle player able to surpass that music, yet it's just the man and his fiddle enjoying a tune.
As a more recent example you should listen to Kevin Crehan's CD, just the fiddle and very well thought out but no production to get in the way, plain good traditional music. That's what we are talking about here.
_________________
Listen, play and have fun!
<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: sweetone on 2002-10-22 13:15 ]</font>
- colomon
- Posts: 2140
- Joined: Thu Aug 30, 2001 6:00 pm
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Tell us something.: Whistle player, aspiring C#/D accordion and flute player, and aspiring tunesmith. Particularly interested in the music of South Sligo and Newfoundland. Inspired by the music of Peter Horan, Fred Finn, Rufus Guinchard, Emile Benoit, and Liz Carroll.
I've got some compositions up at http://www.harmonyware.com/tunes/SolsTunes.html - Location: Midland, Michigan
- Contact:
Yeah, Peter, your examples of "Jane and John Doe competent" musicians would appear to be well-known, well-thought of, indeed great, yet homespun musicians, each with CDs. When I picture competent whistlers, I think of Colleen, Dale, Emily, all from our local session. Actually, competent sounds a lot like an insult applied to them -- they're all good players, but not greats, nor are they exactly household names.
I think this is what causes part of the difference in opinion. I think sweetone and I read the question as, would you rather listen to average musicians or great ones -- witness my including Peter Horan in with the "superstars". You seem to have read it as would you rather listen to great musicians who have a simple style or super-talented flashy musicians.
I think this is what causes part of the difference in opinion. I think sweetone and I read the question as, would you rather listen to average musicians or great ones -- witness my including Peter Horan in with the "superstars". You seem to have read it as would you rather listen to great musicians who have a simple style or super-talented flashy musicians.
- LeeMarsh
- Posts: 1284
- Joined: Sun Jun 10, 2001 6:00 pm
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Location: Odenton, MD (Wash-Baltimore Area)
I'd rather go to the better session player.
Being a good performance or recording musician is not always the same as a good session musician. I've been to sessions where the performance/recording musician was miserable in session, to much individual ego in the way to enjoy the gathering. I've also been around musicians with dozens of credits on dozens of CD's that are simply a joy to have in a session or any informal venue.
If the "star" was one of these later type, I'd pick the "star' session. If the 'star' was one of the former ego-ride types, I'd pick the amature session.
With the ego-centric star type,
it just befuddles me
that the Creator
would put so much music
in such a shallow soul.
I'll choos the session where you ...
_________________
Enjoy Your Music,<br><br><b>Lee Marsh</b><br>
P.S. Just wanted to note that 95 percent of the musicians that I've met who would qualify as 'star' performers are also the type that are a joy to have in session where you see their passion for the music up close and personal.
<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: LeeMarsh on 2002-10-22 15:46 ]</font>
Being a good performance or recording musician is not always the same as a good session musician. I've been to sessions where the performance/recording musician was miserable in session, to much individual ego in the way to enjoy the gathering. I've also been around musicians with dozens of credits on dozens of CD's that are simply a joy to have in a session or any informal venue.
If the "star" was one of these later type, I'd pick the "star' session. If the 'star' was one of the former ego-ride types, I'd pick the amature session.
With the ego-centric star type,
it just befuddles me
that the Creator
would put so much music
in such a shallow soul.
I'll choos the session where you ...
_________________
Enjoy Your Music,<br><br><b>Lee Marsh</b><br>
P.S. Just wanted to note that 95 percent of the musicians that I've met who would qualify as 'star' performers are also the type that are a joy to have in session where you see their passion for the music up close and personal.
<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: LeeMarsh on 2002-10-22 15:46 ]</font>
-
- Posts: 172
- Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2002 6:00 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Vancouver, B.C.
Although I would take the chance to see the stellar performer if I could afford it, I very much agree with Tyghress' point. To me, the real music doesn't happen up there on the stage behind all the microphones and filtered through the preconceptions of the sound guy. Even for those stellar musicians, I think a lot of them would say the best part of being a professional player is getting to play in the living rooms of other pros all around the world, and maybe sometimes in sessions, too. That's where the delight of music happens. So I'd rather spend most of my time in an atmosphere where I can make some kind of contribution, than listening passively or even actively.
But I confess, I have never made a very good audience member. Even as a child, going to a play or concert only filled me with a longing to be in the middle of things. Maybe it's just ego, but I would always rather be doing than observing. When I play CD's, I have to sing or play along, and the concerts I enjoy the most are those where the singers encourage choruses from the audience. The Karen Savoca concert I attended the other night had some of that magic - she's an artist worth listening to, if you get a chance, and her partner is a brilliant guitarist. Not Irish at all, but very down to earth, roots-inspired songs.
But I confess, I have never made a very good audience member. Even as a child, going to a play or concert only filled me with a longing to be in the middle of things. Maybe it's just ego, but I would always rather be doing than observing. When I play CD's, I have to sing or play along, and the concerts I enjoy the most are those where the singers encourage choruses from the audience. The Karen Savoca concert I attended the other night had some of that magic - she's an artist worth listening to, if you get a chance, and her partner is a brilliant guitarist. Not Irish at all, but very down to earth, roots-inspired songs.
My thanks to all who are participating in this thread. The insight and discussion is enlightening.
Peter has some of the essence of my original question when he pointed out that I honestly don't like 'produced' trad music, however grand the musicians. It isn't about personalities! Having met a few top grade musicians who range in temperment from painfully shy to folk-off-the-street-friendly to yeah-I-know-I'm-good, I have to point out that stellar talent and/or professional status doesn't mean they're in-your-face about it, or exude the air that they're too far above you to matter. Just the opposite, really. I'm sure there are obnoxious professional folk musicians. I've just never met any of them. Everyone I've met has been 'nice people'.
But I would prefer spectating at an unfamiliar session than than being in the audience of a professional show. As far as my own sessions...honestly I'd be torn. The Wednesday night session to me is a major social event to me. Let's just say I wouldn't travel [bold]far[/bold] on a Wednesday night to see a pro.
Peter has some of the essence of my original question when he pointed out that I honestly don't like 'produced' trad music, however grand the musicians. It isn't about personalities! Having met a few top grade musicians who range in temperment from painfully shy to folk-off-the-street-friendly to yeah-I-know-I'm-good, I have to point out that stellar talent and/or professional status doesn't mean they're in-your-face about it, or exude the air that they're too far above you to matter. Just the opposite, really. I'm sure there are obnoxious professional folk musicians. I've just never met any of them. Everyone I've met has been 'nice people'.
But I would prefer spectating at an unfamiliar session than than being in the audience of a professional show. As far as my own sessions...honestly I'd be torn. The Wednesday night session to me is a major social event to me. Let's just say I wouldn't travel [bold]far[/bold] on a Wednesday night to see a pro.
Remember, you didn't get the tiger so it would do what you wanted. You got the tiger to see what it wanted to do. -- Colin McEnroe
I was only responding to Sweetone giving two examples of very well played top of the range traditional musicians playing without any overproduction, straightforward vituosity.On 2002-10-22 14:17, colomon wrote:
You seem to have read it as would you rather listen to great musicians who have a simple style or super-talented flashy musicians.
Sweetone still doesn't get the point, considering the musicans he quotes.