Lizzie wrote:The snobbery comment as meant about those who are such purists that their way is THE only way to learn.
Hmmm, that would be me!
I really thought about that stuff this week-end, and wondered why I was so pissed off sometimes about this sheet music thing. Well, it has really nothing to do with sheet music or related technicalities. My real
issue is with people who don't have enough respect or comprehension to try to blend in or fit in some group. It could be applied to anything, not just music. I've seen a few classical musicians who thought really high of themselves and wanted to prove that they could play irish music. Well, not only won't they sound traditional at all, but they won't let people around them play. Many others would just sound like a midi file, tongue every note and disrupt the session dynamic.
I really get much pleasure in listening to some sessions where the phrasing is very traditional, and I dream of having a place in those great sessions one day. Some people will say "it's just a jam, and everyone should have a chance to play" and so on, but I don't believe this. I have lots of respect for those musicians and just by listening I can tell that my music would not fit in some of those sessions because the quality of the music is so high and I don't want to ruin it, but I'm ready to work for it and one day, I'll go there knowing that I can bring something to the music. Well, unfortunately, there's many people who go in sessions just for the heck of playing some notes, sometimes to get heard, sometimes just because they love playing music.
So, going back to the sheet music thing, I think it's just a symptom of the real problem: many don't want to take the time to learn to play the way irish music becomes very enjoyable. I'm not sure if it's ignorance, lack of motivation, lack of taste, etc, but when I hear someone in a good session play like a midi file, and I feel like this person doesnt give a sh*t about playing any other way, it drives me mad. If someone tommorow comes to me and says "I currently play from sheet music but I realize that I don't sound traditional at all, and would like to work on improving this", I would be very helpful to this person. Heck, that person could even play from sheet music
in a session for a while and I would still be happy to be around the person, because I know that he/she respects the music/people he/she wants to play with. The quality of the music isnt everything. There's friendship, seniority, and/or many other things that can make a session fun without very good traditional music, but the lack of effort is something that I don't respect at all, because I guess I don't feel respected when it happens. I guess it's like when you're waiting in queue and someone just goes straight passed everybody. I'm sure this person did the best thing for his/her own good, but he/she affected many people by doing so.