Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

The Ultimate On-Line Whistle Community. If you find one more ultimater, let us know.
luketinwhistle
Posts: 5
Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2012 2:39 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 10

Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by luketinwhistle »

I've been playing tin whistle for about 2 months now and I've been trying to play some irish music like "Ships are Sailing" and "Noel Hills" but whenever i play the second higher octave, it comes out shrill, breathy and very ear piercing and not sweet and pure like i hear other people playing it. I'm using an Oak D Whistle. Does anyone have any advice on playing higher than a high F# that's about as high as i can go without it sounding shrill and breathy. Would something like a Feadog D Brass whistle be better for playing the higher octaves? Thanks!
User avatar
Denny
Posts: 24005
Joined: Mon Nov 17, 2003 11:29 am
antispam: No
Location: N of Seattle

Re: Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by Denny »

Picture a bright blue ball just spinning, spinning free
It's dizzying, the possibilities. Ashes, Ashes all fall down.
User avatar
DrPhill
Posts: 1610
Joined: Wed Nov 19, 2008 11:58 am
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 10
Location: None

Re: Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by DrPhill »

luketinwhistle wrote:I've been playing tin whistle for about 2 months now and I've been trying to play some irish music like "Ships are Sailing" and "Noel Hills" but whenever i play the second higher octave, it comes out shrill, breathy and very ear piercing and not sweet and pure like i hear other people playing it. I'm using an Oak D Whistle. Does anyone have any advice on playing higher than a high F# that's about as high as i can go without it sounding shrill and breathy. Would something like a Feadog D Brass whistle be better for playing the higher octaves? Thanks!
A common problem is blowing too hard, and thinking that you are playing the first octave when you are actually playing the second; then when you try for the next octave up you are attempting the third octave (which I believe has been banned by the Geneva Convention - or should be). I have no experience with the oak so I have no idea how likely it is in your case. You could check against a tuner which reports the octave (flutini might be good, I use Sound color analyzer and Tuner for shakuhachi) High D whistle first octave should be from D5 to D6, second from D6 to D7.

That said, when I started learning (low) whistle it took me ages to get the second octave right. I sort of crept up note by note. Part of my problem was a lack of confidence so I would underblow and sound awful. That sapped my confidence even more. If this is part of your problem, you could try muting your whistle (blue tack, paper clip, etc) just to give you a feel for playing the higher octave. Or find a place where you can blast away without annoying anyone.

Or I could be wrong.....
Phill

One does not equal two. Not even for very large values of one.
User avatar
Flexismart
Posts: 288
Joined: Wed Aug 27, 2008 3:36 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: Some of my original tunes are displayed at https://thesession.org/members/49476
I play several flutes, many whistles, many guitars, bouzouki, banjo, and own way too many pedals.
I could open a music store if I didn't live in the back woods of Pennsylvania.
Location: PA

Re: Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by Flexismart »

Does anyone have any advice on playing higher than a high F#
Simple...really.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MheNUWyROv8
gregwhistle
Posts: 131
Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2011 7:55 am
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 10

Re: Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by gregwhistle »

luketinwhistle wrote:A common problem is blowing too hard, and thinking that you are playing the first octave when you are actually playing the second; then when you try for the next octave up you are attempting the third octave (which I believe has been banned by the Geneva Convention - or should be). I have no experience with the oak so I have no idea how likely it is in your case. You could check against a tuner which reports the octave (flutini might be good, I use Sound color analyzer and Tuner for shakuhachi) High D whistle first octave should be from D5 to D6, second from D6 to D7.
Definitely the first thing to check, as if this is the problem, the solution is both "easy" and, well, absolutely required :)
mwilson
Posts: 31
Joined: Fri Dec 09, 2011 12:38 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 10

Re: Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by mwilson »

I'm in sort of the same boat, playing a couple of months. The big store in town has only Generation and Megs. I started with a Generation D whistle, after a couple of weeks playing very gingerly, got a D Meg and proved that the Generation was one of the duds. Playing anything outside low-A to higher-E on the Generation is an adventure.

On the Meg, anything from low-E to higher-G is pretty much rock-solid. Belltone D will break up an octave if I'm not careful, and higher-A wants to break down to low-A. Overblowing from higher-D first goes up to higher-A, then to a really scary, piercing D that also seems significantly sharp.

I, too, wonder if you're not playing an octave higher than you think. On this D Meg, the octave from G to G is pretty much just there, no problem. The lowest notes from belltone D are very soft and breathy, the second octave starts very clear.

The first tunes I'm practicing stay away from the second octave. I've lifted or copied a few: "Blow the Winds Southerly", "Call the Ewes from the Knolls" (nice little air lifted from a recording by the Glasgow Orpheus Choir), "Quelle est cette Odeur Agreable" (French Christmas carol), "Star of the County Down", "I Know My Love". I'm trying now to get those to the point where somebody would want to hear them. Once I've done that, and I've got solid with the fingering around the octave break, I'll try that barn-burner "Tri Martolod"
User avatar
hoopy mike
Posts: 1395
Joined: Sat May 03, 2008 3:09 am
Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
Location: Nottingham
Contact:

Re: Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by hoopy mike »

Welcome!
mwilson wrote:I'm in sort of the same boat, playing a couple of months. The big store in town has only Generation and Megs. I started with a Generation D whistle, after a couple of weeks playing very gingerly, got a D Meg and proved that the Generation was one of the duds.
Nah - that proves nothing about the whistle. :-)
I think that Megs / Sweetones are easier to play for beginners, but it's worth persevering with other whistles.
User avatar
jkrazy52
Posts: 772
Joined: Tue Apr 06, 2004 1:12 am
Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
Location: Southern Ohio

Re: Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by jkrazy52 »

Practice is the real cure. I will admit to having the about the same problem when I started playing. It was frustrating. The whistles in question for me were a Clark original and a Feadog. It is really not the whistle ... totally. My cure was to buy a Dixon. The squawks disappeared for the most part and I had enough nerve to continue on. A new whistle might help (Meg, Sweetone, Dixon DX005, Park's Ghost) and give you the want to play more. BUT it is the 'play more' that cures the problem. You should eventually appreciate the Oak, and mwilson may eventually like the Generation. :)
User avatar
Thomas-Hastay
Posts: 839
Joined: Tue Jun 26, 2001 6:00 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Location: Between my Ears or in "Nord" East MN
Contact:

Re: Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by Thomas-Hastay »

Try this simple tweak: use a piece of tape to cover 1/3rd to 1/2 of the bore end hole. This will provide more backpressure and allow second octave access with lower breath pressure. It will reduce shrillness because of lower windway velocity. Covering the bottom 2 or 3 toneholes when playing the Upper notes in the second octave can help as well.
"The difference between Genius and stupidity, is that Genius has its limits" (Albert Einstein)
thomashastay@yahoo.com
robert schuler
Posts: 93
Joined: Fri Jun 24, 2011 9:00 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 12
Location: new jersey

Re: Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by robert schuler »

I think the Oak D is the most tempermental of all the inexpensive whistles out there. It has a great tone but you need to pay extra attention to breath control. I have been playing the Oak for a long time and still get hungup on the second octave...You should try a Jerry Freeman Tweaked Gen. D. Its a very forgiving whistle and remarkably stable in the second octave... Bob.
Oh body swayed to music, O brightening glance,
How can we know the dancer from the dance?... WB Yeats
User avatar
Flexismart
Posts: 288
Joined: Wed Aug 27, 2008 3:36 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: Some of my original tunes are displayed at https://thesession.org/members/49476
I play several flutes, many whistles, many guitars, bouzouki, banjo, and own way too many pedals.
I could open a music store if I didn't live in the back woods of Pennsylvania.
Location: PA

Re: Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by Flexismart »

Short of practicing, and if the whistle is a dud (and there are many of them out there), getting a different one,
you could try this. You'd be an instant hit at your local pub.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2iufaT1mLug
User avatar
hoopy mike
Posts: 1395
Joined: Sat May 03, 2008 3:09 am
Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
Location: Nottingham
Contact:

Re: Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by hoopy mike »

Flexismart wrote:Short of practicing, and if the whistle is a dud (and there are many of them out there)...
I suspect that there are more dud whistlers out there than dud whistles.
User avatar
E = Fb
Posts: 510
Joined: Tue Aug 20, 2002 6:00 pm
Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
Location: Heath

Re: Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by E = Fb »

It's the whistle itself, primarily. The player's skill is less than 10% of the problem. Tweaking can reduce this. A tweaked Feadog will do well. In fact, tweaking the Oak will improve it. If you want out-of-the-box sweetness you'll have to go with a more expensive model such as Milligan, etc.
Current stage of grief: Denial
User avatar
Denny
Posts: 24005
Joined: Mon Nov 17, 2003 11:29 am
antispam: No
Location: N of Seattle

Re: Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by Denny »

hoopy mike wrote:
Flexismart wrote:Short of practicing, and if the whistle is a dud (and there are many of them out there)...
I suspect that there are more dud whistlers out there than dud whistles.
all of mine :D :thumbsup:
Picture a bright blue ball just spinning, spinning free
It's dizzying, the possibilities. Ashes, Ashes all fall down.
User avatar
hoopy mike
Posts: 1395
Joined: Sat May 03, 2008 3:09 am
Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
Location: Nottingham
Contact:

Re: Playing the 2nd Octave on the Tin Whistle help?

Post by hoopy mike »

E = Fb wrote:It's the whistle itself, primarily. The player's skill is less than 10% of the problem. Tweaking can reduce this. A tweaked Feadog will do well. In fact, tweaking the Oak will improve it. If you want out-of-the-box sweetness you'll have to go with a more expensive model such as Milligan, etc.
Did someone leave their irony lock turned on?
Post Reply