Are trad. tunes "made for" a certain instrument?

For all instruments -- please read F.A.Q. before posting.
Post Reply
Hooleh
Posts: 128
Joined: Wed Nov 02, 2016 5:04 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: A whistler and a beginner Uilleann piper from Scandinavia. Maybe some day a piper during this life time.

Are trad. tunes "made for" a certain instrument?

Post by Hooleh »

Hey folks,

I was just wondering if some jigs and reels, for instance, are "meant" to be played, say, rather on a fiddle than a whistle or the pipes? I'm a whistler myself, and although I've been at it for some years now, the pub session scene is still quite new to me. I have been going to a small-ish monthly pub session for some time that has a long-time fiddler there, and I've been learning many tunes that they've played there over the years. Anyway the point is that some tunes just seem to come out of the whistle way easier than others. I mean, so far I have been able to learn every tune that I've tried to learn, but somehow with some tunes I get the feeling that this tune would be so much better played on a fiddle.

Is there any truth to this that tunes have been and are "planned" for a certain instrument to be most suitable to play with that particular instrument, or the contrary, that is, meant to be "universal" as in suitable to be learned with any traditional instrument?

Just some thoughts of mine! Hopefully I make some sense.
User avatar
Nanohedron
Moderatorer
Posts: 38211
Joined: Wed Dec 18, 2002 6:00 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: Been a fluter, citternist, and uilleann piper; committed now to the way of the harp.

Oh, yeah: also a mod here, not a spammer. A matter of opinion, perhaps.
Location: Lefse country

Re: Are trad. tunes "made for" a certain instrument?

Post by Nanohedron »

I think the only real limitations concern range, damn those fiddlers and box players. :wink:

Is a tune composed on the pipes a pipe tune? Sure. Flute for flute? Of course. Should a whistler avoid playing a fiddle tune? Not for that reason. The main question for me was always, does it sound good? There are fiddle tunes I wouldn't play outside of sessions because I just didn't like how they sounded on flute, but folding out of necessity wasn't always the reason. And to be fair, sometimes it was. Odds are that a tune composed on your instrument will be relatively easier to play than on any other instrument, but in the end it's not axiomatic.

Are there tunes specifically composed for certain instruments? Yes. The late great box player, Paddy O'Brien of Nenagh, composed some of his tunes specifically with the uilleann pipes in mind. I would say that's ample reason not to worry whether you'd be overstepping bounds in playing them, if the question occurs. :)
"If you take music out of this world, you will have nothing but a ball of fire." - Tribal musician
User avatar
MadmanWithaWhistle
Posts: 697
Joined: Fri Jan 27, 2012 10:15 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: Instrument maker and researcher exploring new methods of creating traditional instruments with longevity aforethought. Player of the whistle, flute, and continental European border pipes.

Re: Are trad. tunes "made for" a certain instrument?

Post by MadmanWithaWhistle »

Except for those wankers like Paddy Taylor playing a Radcliffe system flute! All those supposed "flute tunes" of his in A major are such a pain! :lol:
Tunborough
Posts: 1419
Joined: Sun Dec 05, 2010 2:59 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 10
Location: Southwestern Ontario

Re: Are trad. tunes "made for" a certain instrument?

Post by Tunborough »

I would say that some melodic passages fit better on some instruments than others. One tune I play has a fast BcdBcd passage (C-nat, that is) that is tough on the whistle, but a piece of cake on the fiddle's A string. But then it continues with dDdDE, which is easier on the whistle.

And (a bit off-topic) don't ask a brass player to play fast chromatic scales.
User avatar
benhall.1
Moderator
Posts: 14797
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2009 5:21 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: I'm a fiddler and, latterly, a fluter. I love the flute. I wish I'd always played it. I love the whistle as well. I'm blessed in having really lovely instruments for all of my musical interests.
Location: Unimportant island off the great mainland of Europe

Re: Are trad. tunes "made for" a certain instrument?

Post by benhall.1 »

MadmanWithaWhistle wrote:Except for those wankers like Paddy Taylor playing a Radcliffe system flute! All those supposed "flute tunes" of his in A major are such a pain! :lol:
I didn't think Paddy Taylor played a Radcliff (no 'e') system. Wasn't that a different Paddy?

Added later: Ah, don't mind me. It was Paddy Carty I was thinking of, but I see that, although Paddy Taylor did play a simple system (8-key) flute, he also played a Radcliff system flute. So, there we are.
awildman
Posts: 612
Joined: Thu Nov 09, 2006 12:44 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Location: Washington State

Re: Are trad. tunes "made for" a certain instrument?

Post by awildman »

Yes, some tunes sit much better on one instrument than another. It seems as if the author of some tunes composed them with a specific instrument in hand.

Of course, you can modify just about any tune to play on your instrument. Leave out a roll(especially that pesky B roll), hold a main note longer to avoid some tough notes etc. There's no reason a tune has to be played exactly the same on whistle as fiddle, and probably shouldn't be.

Even further, the more you play and get experience, many of the awkward fingerings will become normal to you. Keep at it!
Flutulator
Posts: 63
Joined: Sat Feb 25, 2017 11:33 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: Here for a bit to get info on adding another keyed lefty flute to my instrument collection. Preferably something from a highly respected maker. Been playing since 2006.
Location: Where the mud roams wild

Re: Are trad. tunes "made for" a certain instrument?

Post by Flutulator »

awildman wrote:Yes, some tunes sit much better on one instrument than another. It seems as if the author of some tunes composed them with a specific instrument in hand.

Of course, you can modify just about any tune to play on your instrument. Leave out a roll(especially that pesky B roll), hold a main note longer to avoid some tough notes etc. There's no reason a tune has to be played exactly the same on whistle as fiddle, and probably shouldn't be.

Even further, the more you play and get experience, many of the awkward fingerings will become normal to you. Keep at it!
I have heard rumors that it's possible to play Eddie Kelly's reel on a simple system flute.

I have also heard rumors of UFOs and Bigfoot sightings.
My name is John. It is NOT "OP." :) :)
Post Reply