Hi everyone -
curious what the deal is with the basses on the 3 row diatonic button accordions -- every once and a while you'll see a 3 row on ebay -- a B/C/C# with 48 bass --
how do the basses on one of these work? Are they a stradella bass similar to what is on a PA? With the basses, do you get the same note on the press and the draw? I presume on the trebles it's similar to other button boxes -- a different note on the press and the draw --
it would be pretty neat if you could combine the bass side of a PA and the distinctive sound of the button box on the right hand -- is this how these 3 rows work?
Thanks,
Ted
3 row diatonic button accordions
-
- Posts: 21
- Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 2:22 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Minneapolis Minnesota
3 row diatonic button accordions
Accordionly yours,
Tedrick Schmenke
Tedrick Schmenke
- StevieJ
- Posts: 2189
- Joined: Thu May 17, 2001 6:00 pm
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Tell us something.: Old hand, active in the early 2000s. Less active in recent years but still lurking from time to time.
- Location: Montreal
Re: 3 row diatonic button accordions
how do the basses on one of these work? Are they a stradella bass similar to what is on a PA?
- Yes!
With the basses, do you get the same note on the press and the draw?
- Yes!
I presume on the trebles it's similar to other button boxes -- a different note on the press and the draw --
- Yes!
it would be pretty neat if you could combine the bass side of a PA and the distinctive sound of the button box on the right hand -- is this how these 3 rows work?
- Yes!
They are neat, but _very_ heavy. As I understand it they were developed by the Scottish accordionist Jimmy Shand (who until then had been a B/C player) in conjunction with Hohner. Having the extra C# row means that you have all the accidentals in the other direction (relative to the B row) and there are only a few notes of the C scale that are not available in the other direction("reversed"). This means you can play in a very fluid style and also play easily many of the exotic keys that are very awkward on a B/C.
Having so many keys available, the usual diatonic basses would be even more useless than they are on a two-row, so it made sense to put a stradella bass end on them.
They are still pretty popular in Scotland but only a few old-timers still use them in Ireland, where they were quite common in the 1950s I think. The English squeezebox supremo John Kirkpatrick plays one too.
Here's one in full flight: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d5pc53pYnhs
They are stretching the limits of the diatonic principle, though. Given the weight I think I'd sooner go for a continental chromatic and I believe Jimmy Shand himself is on record as saying that if he had to start over, that's the route he would go.
People have married two-row right hands to stradella basses though for a lighter box with similar bass flexibility and some makers will make such an animal for you.
Edited to add: video clip of an Irish musician who knows his way around one. Trite song but there are some nice reel snippets in between the verses. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=29vHWKDvc9w
- Yes!
With the basses, do you get the same note on the press and the draw?
- Yes!
I presume on the trebles it's similar to other button boxes -- a different note on the press and the draw --
- Yes!
it would be pretty neat if you could combine the bass side of a PA and the distinctive sound of the button box on the right hand -- is this how these 3 rows work?
- Yes!
They are neat, but _very_ heavy. As I understand it they were developed by the Scottish accordionist Jimmy Shand (who until then had been a B/C player) in conjunction with Hohner. Having the extra C# row means that you have all the accidentals in the other direction (relative to the B row) and there are only a few notes of the C scale that are not available in the other direction("reversed"). This means you can play in a very fluid style and also play easily many of the exotic keys that are very awkward on a B/C.
Having so many keys available, the usual diatonic basses would be even more useless than they are on a two-row, so it made sense to put a stradella bass end on them.
They are still pretty popular in Scotland but only a few old-timers still use them in Ireland, where they were quite common in the 1950s I think. The English squeezebox supremo John Kirkpatrick plays one too.
Here's one in full flight: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d5pc53pYnhs
They are stretching the limits of the diatonic principle, though. Given the weight I think I'd sooner go for a continental chromatic and I believe Jimmy Shand himself is on record as saying that if he had to start over, that's the route he would go.
People have married two-row right hands to stradella basses though for a lighter box with similar bass flexibility and some makers will make such an animal for you.
Edited to add: video clip of an Irish musician who knows his way around one. Trite song but there are some nice reel snippets in between the verses. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=29vHWKDvc9w
-
- Posts: 21
- Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 2:22 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Minneapolis Minnesota
Re: 3 row diatonic button accordions
Thanks StevieJ -
Wow... is the accordion a great instrument or what?
My goal is to be able to add chord accompaniment with the left hand -- the stradella system is the way to go --
After playing the PA a bit and starting to learn the stradella bass system, I think the basses on the diatonic B/C are a cruel joke.
Does anyone have any good youtube vids showing the basses being fully used on a diatonic button accordion? I'd just like to hear how the chord accompaniment is supposed to sound when done properly.
We get a very good button accordionist playing at the feis' here in the midwest, Michael Fitzpatrick, who I believe is playing a standard diatonic button accordion.
Wow... is the accordion a great instrument or what?
My goal is to be able to add chord accompaniment with the left hand -- the stradella system is the way to go --
After playing the PA a bit and starting to learn the stradella bass system, I think the basses on the diatonic B/C are a cruel joke.
Does anyone have any good youtube vids showing the basses being fully used on a diatonic button accordion? I'd just like to hear how the chord accompaniment is supposed to sound when done properly.
We get a very good button accordionist playing at the feis' here in the midwest, Michael Fitzpatrick, who I believe is playing a standard diatonic button accordion.
Accordionly yours,
Tedrick Schmenke
Tedrick Schmenke
Re: 3 row diatonic button accordions
Hi Ted
Check out the site below. There are some BCC# players there. Also there is a keyboard layout for a 34 treble and 48 bass like John Kirkpatrick plays. Recently I started playing a 37 treble/80 bass Paolo Soprani BCC#. I love it.
Good luck
Brian
http://info.melodeon.net/
Check out the site below. There are some BCC# players there. Also there is a keyboard layout for a 34 treble and 48 bass like John Kirkpatrick plays. Recently I started playing a 37 treble/80 bass Paolo Soprani BCC#. I love it.
Good luck
Brian
http://info.melodeon.net/
-
- Posts: 21
- Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 2:22 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Minneapolis Minnesota
Re: 3 row diatonic button accordions
Thanks Brian --
so with the B/C/C# --- on the B/C rows -- it behave just like a B/C box, right? Then you add that C# row to get functionality in other keys? Could you transpose a tune you know with the B/C fingerings to the key it would be in if you played it in the same spot on the C/C# rows?
How do you find the basses? Do you primarily use a drone style or do you do bass/counterbass like a PA would do?
Thanks! I am intrigued enough to consider selling my B/C to get into one of these 3 rows....
Ted
so with the B/C/C# --- on the B/C rows -- it behave just like a B/C box, right? Then you add that C# row to get functionality in other keys? Could you transpose a tune you know with the B/C fingerings to the key it would be in if you played it in the same spot on the C/C# rows?
How do you find the basses? Do you primarily use a drone style or do you do bass/counterbass like a PA would do?
Thanks! I am intrigued enough to consider selling my B/C to get into one of these 3 rows....
Ted
Accordionly yours,
Tedrick Schmenke
Tedrick Schmenke