Question for Box players: B/C or D/G?

We have some evidence, however, that you may have to pay for the reeds.
User avatar
Ro3b
Posts: 777
Joined: Wed Nov 13, 2002 6:00 pm
Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
Location: Takoma Park, MD
Contact:

Post by Ro3b »

Ditto all that Steve said.
- Is it easier to play fast jigs and reels on a B/C than on a C#/D?
Like superfast? Over 120 bpm? Yes. But for normal sane session/ceili tempos, I don't think so, not once you're past the beginner stage.
- Is the B/C more versatile and easier to play than the C#/D?
I haven't really found that to be the case. Some things are trickier in one system than the other -- the key of G doesn't lie as nicely under the fingers on the C#/D keyboard, for example. On the other hand, on the B/C the A scale is almost all on the pull, so you have to use your air button with extreme cleverness. One thing I do like about the B/C is that with all the outside-row notes, crossing fingers over for shifts is a breeze. I had to get comfortable with shifting on the same row when I switched to C#/D. It still feels slightly clunky to me.
- Does the C#/D offer more opportunities to play bass/chords/harmonies in D major and G major tunes?
YES. Definitely. That's one of the reasons I switched over to C#/D. It's a lot easier to figure harmonies and chords out. And the basses make a lot more sense too -- each pair of bass buttons gives you I and V chords in a particular key.
Cayden

Post by Cayden »

Ro3b wrote:
- Does the C#/D offer more opportunities to play bass/chords/harmonies in D major and G major tunes?
YES. Definitely. That's one of the reasons I switched over to C#/D. It's a lot easier to figure harmonies and chords out. And the basses make a lot more sense too -- each pair of bass buttons gives you I and V chords in a particular key.
There's this story I have heard Jackie Daly tell dozens of times: One night he was playing a cocnert somewhere, Joe Burke was on as well and Joe was in a panic 'Jackie Jackie what am I going to do one of my basses doesn't work' 'Well Joe' Jackie replied, 'you could try using a different one' Image
User avatar
claudine
Posts: 1128
Joined: Tue Jun 26, 2001 6:00 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: Hi, I am a choir singer from Luxembourg trying to get back to Irish flute playing after a few years of absence from ITM.
Location: Luxembourg

Post by claudine »

thanks for your advice. C#/D shall be my choice then.
Post Reply