confused with - whistle - notation - other instruments ...

The Ultimate On-Line Whistle Community. If you find one more ultimater, let us know.
Post Reply
User avatar
German Whistler
Posts: 337
Joined: Thu Jul 05, 2012 12:25 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 10
Location: Germany / NRW
Contact:

confused with - whistle - notation - other instruments ...

Post by German Whistler »

the title is a bit "confused" or "confusing" but i am confused too

to explain my confusion/question, let me use an example
if i have the notation for a tune/song, lets say "morning has broken" (just because i found this on the top of my desk right now) and its not written 4 whistles and it goes like
EXAMPLE:

___________C__Dm__G_________F____C_______<- chords 4 guitar
Morning has bro-ken like the first mor-ning______<- Text ;-)
C___E___G__c*__d*__B__A__G___A___G_______<- notes 4 voice, or in this case whistle
so there is a C i cant play on my D whistle, i could take a C whistle, BUT it would be to much for me, to make in my mind a "D" out of an "C", and so on, to realize how to do the fingering in this case
...oh my, this sound so weired but i hope its clear what i mean, is it?

so i "transcribe"(is that the right word?) this tune into
4 whistle(D or deepest tone a “D”):
D F A d* e* c* B A B A
now i can play it on a D whistle in the well known fingering, but play it higher as in the notation
or i can use a C whistle, use this fingering as i would on a d whistle and play it as suposed, right? or not?

what happen if i want to play this song on my guitar and whistle together?
is it ok if i know use the C whistle, or...?
i ask this because i have plenty notations which use a lower tone than the D so i cant play it on my whistles and, untill now always "tranbscribe" it which is a lot of work for me
what do you do when you have such notation, can you "fix this in your mind" do you "transcribe it",...?
i guess some more experiance with dots and also some more understanding in musictheory would help me, but i am not so far yet
Andreas Fischer the "German Whistler"
PLay Whistles since May 2012

* My Whistles and other Instruments
* My WeBlog
Recommendation:
* My (Your) Music Community
A monthly Learn and Compare Challenge and more!
Everybody is welcome and U 2
;-)
retired
Posts: 382
Joined: Wed Dec 29, 2010 6:34 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 12

Re: confused with - whistle - notation - other instruments ...

Post by retired »

GW - Rather than transcribing, I think it would be a lot easier if you played it on the C whistle and just spent a little time getting to know the notes on that whistle - actually it's the easiest one to remember as there are no sharps or flats - C D E F G A B c rather than D E F# G A B d . Hope this simple explanation helps if I understand your question correctly.
User avatar
German Whistler
Posts: 337
Joined: Thu Jul 05, 2012 12:25 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 10
Location: Germany / NRW
Contact:

Re: confused with - whistle - notation - other instruments ...

Post by German Whistler »

i do understand that the c whistle gives me C D E F G A B ... instead of D E F# G A B (d whistle)

but is it realy the usual way to learn all the notzes oin each whistle?
is it not easier to learn it on one (the d) whistle and then use whistles in different keys to play in different keys?
i tought thats on of the special things with whistles that you can use the same fingering for to play in different keys

with your solution i would have to learn the notes on all whistles in each keys, right?
Andreas Fischer the "German Whistler"
PLay Whistles since May 2012

* My Whistles and other Instruments
* My WeBlog
Recommendation:
* My (Your) Music Community
A monthly Learn and Compare Challenge and more!
Everybody is welcome and U 2
;-)
User avatar
Feadoggie
Posts: 3940
Joined: Mon Feb 14, 2005 11:06 pm
antispam: No
Location: Stout's Valley, PA, USA

Re: confused with - whistle - notation - other instruments ...

Post by Feadoggie »

German Whistler wrote:is it not easier to learn it on one (the d) whistle and then use whistles in different keys to play in different keys? i tought thats on of the special things with whistles that you can use the same fingering for to play in different keys
It works in all directions not just from a D whistle then on to another whistle. if the original piece is in C it still works the same way. Learn it on a C whistle and then play it with the same fingerings on any other whistle as you used on the C whistle.

Besides, most of us don't think much about what the notes are that we are playing in most tunes. Yes, we can stop and think about it if we like but most off us are just playing the intervals not caring particularly which whistle we are playing them on. It's called "playing". Right?

Feadoggie
I've proven who I am so many times, the magnetic strips worn thin.
User avatar
Jleo Fipple
Posts: 334
Joined: Wed Jul 25, 2012 8:11 am
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Location: The Emerald Isle
Contact:

Re: confused with - whistle - notation - other instruments ...

Post by Jleo Fipple »

Feadoggie wrote: ...but most off us are just playing the intervals not caring particularly which whistle we are playing them on.
Holy Cacophony Bat Man!!
I'll remind myself to avoid any sets you play in should I chance to meet you at a session :lol:
German Whistler wrote:i do understand that the c whistle gives me C D E F G A B ... instead of D E F# G A B (d whistle)

but is it really the usual way to learn all the notzes oin each whistle?
is it not easier to learn it on one (the d) whistle and then use whistles in different keys to play in different keys?
i tought thats on of the special things with whistles that you can use the same fingering for to play in different keys

with your solution i would have to learn the notes on all whistles in each keys, right?
Andreas,

As you know a tune learned on the D whistle can be easily played on any other whistle key. What you have also realised is that to learn to play a tune written in C requires you to play the C whistle with C fingerings and that's not easy if you have become accustomed to playing on D whistle. It's not an impossible task but would take much time dedicated to whistle to be able to sight read and play for any whistle key. So for now I reckon transposing is the easier option, especially if you are in the learning stages of reading standard music notation.
German Whistler wrote: i ask this because i have plenty notations which use a lower tone than the D so i cant play it on my whistles and, untill now always "tranbscribe" it which is a lot of work for me
For transposing I would suggest EasyABC it will also exercise your sight reading skills and is easy to use with play back and transposing tools built in.

The best tip for getting started in EasyAbc is to load a tune you know then alter it in the editor,
for example change a note value and find it in the notation and understand how your edit has altered original notation it's a simple but effective exercise for anyone with a basic knowledge of standard music notation.

EasyAbc info and download
EasyABC

"Morning has broken"
EasyAbc transpose
X:1
T:Morning has broken
M:3/4
L:1/4
R:Mor
K:Dmaj
DFA|d3|e3|cBA|BcB|!
A3|DEF|A3|B3|AFD|!
D E2|AFA|d3|B3|AFE|D3|!
E3|FEF|A3|B3|EFE|D3]
Last edited by Jleo Fipple on Fri Apr 26, 2013 10:37 am, edited 11 times in total.
User avatar
fearfaoin
Posts: 7975
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2003 10:31 am
antispam: No
Location: Raleigh, NC
Contact:

Re: confused with - whistle - notation - other instruments ...

Post by fearfaoin »

German Whistler wrote:but is it realy the usual way to learn all the notzes oin each whistle?
It is not, and I wouldn't recommend it. I think it's bad advice.
Transposing for instruments is a long-standing tradition.
The Clarinet, for example, is properly called a "Bb clarinet" because its music is transposed. If you play a Bb on a piano, you would play the fingering that we call "C" on the clarinet and the notes would sound the same.
This is normal and desirable. If a clarinetist suddenly got it into her head to play the Eb Alto Clarinet she would not have to learn new fingerings because the person who wrote the sheet music for the orchestra already transposed the notes for Eb Alto Clarinet. The clarinetist can use the same fingerings that she is used to on her Bb Clarinet for the notes she sees in front of her and everything sounds magically happy.

Another reason we do this is it makes it a little easier to change between woodwinds. For example, a "D" fingering is the same on the flute, on the Alto sax, on the Tenor Sax, on the D whistle, on the oboe, on the upper register of the Clarinet, etc.

Now, you don't have a composer transposing the music for you, but it's really not a hard skill. If you can count, you can transpose.
User avatar
Jleo Fipple
Posts: 334
Joined: Wed Jul 25, 2012 8:11 am
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Location: The Emerald Isle
Contact:

Re: confused with - whistle - notation - other instruments ...

Post by Jleo Fipple »

German Whistler wrote: what happen if i want to play this song on my guitar and whistle together?
is it ok if i know use the C whistle, or...?
When you transpose the C notation to D you also need to transpose the accompanying guitars chords to the key of D also. See below,

Morning has broken
Key - D major - Chords
___________D__Em__A_________G____D_______<- chords 4 guitar

Morning has broken
Key - C major - Chords
___________C__Dm__G_________F____C_______<- chords 4 guitar
Last edited by Jleo Fipple on Fri Apr 26, 2013 12:29 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
hans
Posts: 2259
Joined: Fri Nov 01, 2002 6:00 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: I've been making whistles since 2010 in my tiny workshop at my home. I've been playing whistle since teenage times.
Location: Moray Firth, Scotland
Contact:

Re: confused with - whistle - notation - other instruments ...

Post by hans »

Jleo Fipple wrote: When you transpose the C notation to D you also need to transpose the accompanying guitars chords to the key of D also. See below,

Morning has broken
Key - D major - Chords
___________D__Em__A_________G____D_______<- chords 4 guitar

Morning has broken
Key - C major - Chords
___________C__Dm__G_________F____C_______<- chords 4 guitar
That may be true if you play the tune/song on a D whistle.
But if you play it on a C whistle, as if it is a D whistle, then you won't need to transpose your guitar chords, because you really are playing it in C.

Andreas, I think you got the transposing into a D-whistle setting right, you just did not call it transposing :)
User avatar
Jleo Fipple
Posts: 334
Joined: Wed Jul 25, 2012 8:11 am
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Location: The Emerald Isle
Contact:

Re: confused with - whistle - notation - other instruments ...

Post by Jleo Fipple »

hans wrote:
Jleo Fipple wrote: When you transpose the C notation to D you also need to transpose the accompanying guitars chords to the key of D also. See below,

Morning has broken
Key - D major - Chords
___________D__Em__A_________G____D_______<- chords 4 guitar

Morning has broken
Key - C major - Chords
___________C__Dm__G_________F____C_______<- chords 4 guitar
That may be true if you play the tune/song on a D whistle.
But if you play it on a C whistle, as if it is a D whistle, then you won't need to transpose your guitar chords, because you really are playing it in C.
Correct indeed :D
User avatar
German Whistler
Posts: 337
Joined: Thu Jul 05, 2012 12:25 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 10
Location: Germany / NRW
Contact:

Re: confused with - whistle - notation - other instruments ...

Post by German Whistler »

things becomming clearer now, thanks folks
Andreas Fischer the "German Whistler"
PLay Whistles since May 2012

* My Whistles and other Instruments
* My WeBlog
Recommendation:
* My (Your) Music Community
A monthly Learn and Compare Challenge and more!
Everybody is welcome and U 2
;-)
User avatar
hans
Posts: 2259
Joined: Fri Nov 01, 2002 6:00 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: I've been making whistles since 2010 in my tiny workshop at my home. I've been playing whistle since teenage times.
Location: Moray Firth, Scotland
Contact:

Re: confused with - whistle - notation - other instruments ...

Post by hans »

Andreas, if you have a lot of songs written in the keys of C and F, it may be worthwhile to learn playing a C whistle and reading the sheet music for these keys directly. It saves you a lot of transposition work. It will tax your brain for a while, but I think learning to read the music in keys of C and F playing a C whistle is a useful thing, next to learning to read music notated in keys of D and G and playing it on a D whistle. C is the next most useful whistle key.

Followed by Bb, for music in Bb and Eb. With three whistles you got 7 major keys covered, from 3 flats (Eb) to 3 sharps (A, played on a D whistle). So you don't really need to learn reading music for 12 different whistle keys. 2 or perhaps 3 should be enough for most cases.

If you learn to sight-read music from sheet music you will adapt to read for a C whistle, and for a Bb whistle if needed. You won't think about the note names. For Bb everything is just one line on the staff lower than D, which is easy to see. For C it is half a line lower (one tone lower than D).

But if you got the songs in your head, and play the guitar, you can just grab the whistle which fits the guitar setting, and do it by ear. Much preferable than reading dots or mucking about with transpositions!
User avatar
hoopy mike
Posts: 1395
Joined: Sat May 03, 2008 3:09 am
Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
Location: Nottingham
Contact:

Re: confused with - whistle - notation - other instruments ...

Post by hoopy mike »

German Whistler wrote:what happen if i want to play this song on my guitar and whistle together?
You'll need another pair of hands!

As well as the other sensible options mentioned by others, you could transpose the tune into D and play it on your D whistle and put a capo on the guitar at the second fret.
Post Reply