Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

The Ultimate On-Line Whistle Community. If you find one more ultimater, let us know.
Post Reply
Mikethebook
Posts: 1803
Joined: Fri Sep 02, 2011 3:04 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: May 2022, I'm a second-time beginner to the whistle and low whistle after a three-year gap due to a chest injury brought to an end twelve years of playing. I've started on a high whistle and much is coming back quickly but it will be a while before I can manage a Low D again where my interest really lies. I chiefly love slow airs rather than dance tunes and am a fan of the likes of Davy Spillane, Eoin Duignan, Fred Morrison and Paddy Keenan.
Location: Scotland

Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

Post by Mikethebook »

I'm attracted by the above three whistles that have become grouped together because of their similarities in design and can afford to buy one only. But would like to know which of them possesses the most backpressure and which, not necessarily the same, the least air usage. Thoughts please. Many thanks.
User avatar
Average Whistler
Posts: 38
Joined: Sun May 02, 2021 6:11 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: Recovering Whistle Obsessive Acquisition Disorder sufferer. Started too late in life to be great, but good enough for my own enjoyment. Recently started learning Irish flute.
Location: Toronto, Canada

Re: Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

Post by Average Whistler »

I have owned both the Wild Irish and Killarney. The Killarney requires the least air and has decent back-pressure. It is an all-around performer, very popular on this forum. Sweet tone, in tune through both octaves, very responsive. It is one of my go-to whistles and I will never sell it.

I sent the Wild Irish back when the brass insert separated from the fipple and McNeela refused to replace it... thankfully I was within the return window and sent it back for a refund. It sounded great (at first), is loud and very top-heavy due to the head design.

The Lir is very similar build to the Wild Irish and I suspect they come from the same overseas factory. Check out this thread viewtopic.php?p=1252404#p1252404 to read about the Quality issues that a number of forum users have reported about the Lir.

Good luck in your decision.

AW
User avatar
stringbed
Posts: 188
Joined: Tue Apr 12, 2022 9:36 am
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: Playing woodwind instruments for over 70 years and deeply interested in their history, manufacture, technology, and performance practices.
Location: Sweden
Contact:

Re: Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

Post by stringbed »

Average Whistler wrote: Sat Jul 16, 2022 12:03 pm The Lir is very similar build to the Wild Irish and I suspect they come from the same overseas factory.
I share that suspicion and would add Mullan to the list. Killarney is the only one of them that explicitly indicates the country of manufacture.
JackL
Posts: 22
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2022 7:48 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: I have been involved with music starting with piano in 1st grade, switched to organ in 6th grade and minored in music (organ) in college. I have become interested in tin whistle and already have a case of whistle acquisition disease.
Location: Baltimore area, Maryland, USA

Re: Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

Post by JackL »

I have a Killarney and it is beautifully crafted. The tuning is very good and it moves easily between octaves. The only fault I find with it is that it seems to clog with condensate quite easily even when warmed up. I also have a high D aluminum Tilbury; it has similar characteristics but doesn't seem to clog as easily. As such, I prefer it over the Killarney. It is a little more expensive than the Killarney, but not in the same range as some of the other higher end makers. I am not really sensitive to how much air it needs, so cannot comment on that.
Narzog
Posts: 498
Joined: Mon Jun 08, 2020 9:21 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: Can play several instruments at an unimpressive level. Currently most interested in whistling with a side of acoustic guitar.

Re: Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

Post by Narzog »

All I know is avoid all these bad factory lookalikes. The quality isnt there. To my knowledge Killarney is handmade. If it is 'factory' made or partially mass produced by some shop, its at least made well with high quality control. Which is good enough. No reason to support these bad cash grab factory whistles when you can spend a bit more and know what your getting is quality.
User avatar
ecadre
Posts: 273
Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2015 2:59 am
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Location: Coventry, England

Re: Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

Post by ecadre »

Narzog wrote: Sun Jul 17, 2022 9:52 am All I know is avoid all these bad factory lookalikes. The quality isnt there. To my knowledge Killarney is handmade. If it is 'factory' made or partially mass produced by some shop, its at least made well with high quality control. Which is good enough. No reason to support these bad cash grab factory whistles when you can spend a bit more and know what your getting is quality.
Careful there, both the Wild Irish and Lir whistles are more expensive than the Killarney; whatever they are.

Also, on the "handmade" versus "factory made" front. We know very little of the manufacturing processes used to make of any of these whistles and "handmade" is too often a marketing ploy that means nothing much.
Narzog
Posts: 498
Joined: Mon Jun 08, 2020 9:21 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: Can play several instruments at an unimpressive level. Currently most interested in whistling with a side of acoustic guitar.

Re: Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

Post by Narzog »

ecadre wrote: Sun Jul 17, 2022 1:41 pm Careful there, both the Wild Irish and Lir whistles are more expensive than the Killarney; whatever they are.

Also, on the "handmade" versus "factory made" front. We know very little of the manufacturing processes used to make of any of these whistles and "handmade" is too often a marketing ploy that means nothing much.
Your right on pricing, I thought the wild whistle especially was cheaper. I'm thinking of a different made in china lookalike that was like $50 ish. If they cost more that makes even less reason people should be buying these other ones.

Yes we have no idea how killarney are actually made, if its in a workshop, factory, machine shop mass producing parts for them, etc. all I know is I've never heard of 1 quality control issue. So whatever they are doing is good. I myself dont believe 'hand made' is superior to quality mass production. I would trust a professional machine shop to be able to make blocks, tubes etc with more quality than I can, to my specs, in a lot less time. It just seems like most of the time the mass produced stuff isnt the highest of quality to have as big a margin as possible.
User avatar
Mr.Gumby
Posts: 6603
Joined: Mon Jun 07, 2010 11:31 am
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Location: the Back of Beyond

Re: Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

Post by Mr.Gumby »

all I know is I've never heard of 1 quality control issue
Best read up on the earlier threads, I would suggest.

It's all water under the bridge but it hasn't always been plain sailing,especially early on.

The D and Eb they sent me are lovely players but workmanship was a bit shoddy, Ill fitting parts and missing pins, that sort of thing. Things that would have put me off buying, had I encountered them in a shop. Things that should not have been sent out.

But they seem to successfully have cleaned up their act and scaled up their operation since.
My brain hurts

Image
JackL
Posts: 22
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2022 7:48 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: I have been involved with music starting with piano in 1st grade, switched to organ in 6th grade and minored in music (organ) in college. I have become interested in tin whistle and already have a case of whistle acquisition disease.
Location: Baltimore area, Maryland, USA

Re: Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

Post by JackL »

Mr. Gumby, for perspective, when was your experience with the early Killarney whistles?
bigsciota
Posts: 519
Joined: Fri Jun 14, 2013 7:15 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8

Re: Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

Post by bigsciota »

This is a bit of thread drift, but I'll say that the early experience (mine and others) with Killarney was still generally positive, but as Mr. Gumby says not entirely consistent. I have two, a D bought c.2014 and an Eb bought c. 2017. The D definitely looks like an early model of something, came with some tooling marks and scratches and the brass/delrin in the head isn't entirely flush (off by a tiny bit). The Eb is a step up, came clean and shiny and everything's pretty much flush. Now I see they've added a fancy engraved logo and such (both have no brand or key marks). They seem to have come a ways in fit and finish, and as Mr. Gumby says you can read some old threads to see that my experience of the earlier Killarneys is not rare.

I knew people who got Killarneys early on and the tuning was off, or they just didn't play right. Not many, and IIRC the makers were good about making things right if asked. But there were a couple bumps in the road. To be expected, really, for a new maker that got so popular so quickly like they did. The D and Eb I have both play wonderfully, and I play them often. I'd certainly recommend them to anyone looking for a whistle with low air usage.
User avatar
RoberTunes
Posts: 326
Joined: Tue Oct 01, 2019 3:33 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: I am a flute, guitar, keyboard + whistle player learning about quality whistles, musical possibilities and playing techniques. I've recorded a CD of my own music and am creating music for kids.
Location: North America

Re: Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

Post by RoberTunes »

bigsciota wrote: Sun Jul 17, 2022 9:13 pm ........... a couple bumps in the road. To be expected, really, for a new maker that got so popular so quickly like they did. The D and Eb I have both play wonderfully, and I play them often. I'd certainly recommend them to anyone looking for a whistle with low air usage.
Imagine, a company actually starting business and then rapidly increasing the quality and design of their products! Changing, evolving, improving, caring about their product and their customers, responding to feedback. Will this sort of thing catch on in the UK?
User avatar
Mr.Gumby
Posts: 6603
Joined: Mon Jun 07, 2010 11:31 am
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Location: the Back of Beyond

Re: Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

Post by Mr.Gumby »

Will this sort of thing catch on in the UK?
How do you feel that is relevant to anything discussed on this thread?
My brain hurts

Image
whistlelaurie
Posts: 1
Joined: Fri Sep 16, 2022 10:58 am
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: I play tin whistle and own a number of different whistles in different keys, like most of you, I imagine. Always looking for the "perfect" high D whistle, I read this website often.

Re: Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

Post by whistlelaurie »

I bought a high D McNeela Wild whistle. I'm busy comparing it to my other D whistles. I like that it's a little heavier than others and I don't mind that it is black. It is fairly easy to play and has a great lower octave. I like the chaffy sound of it. The upper octave is a bit hard to be in tune on F and G and A unless you are playing fairly loudly. Those notes come out a little flat when played softly. Maybe this is typical of D whistles and is part of the "sound". My new whistle is tuned as sharp as I can physically make it go and the lower octave F, G and A are then perfectly in tune. I wish I had more leeway. However, I have run into this same issue with several of my Dixon whistles in that they are also not able to be tuned much higher than what is good for the lower octave. That said, I am liking the power and ease of playing this new whistle and the price is very reasonable.
Narzog
Posts: 498
Joined: Mon Jun 08, 2020 9:21 pm
antispam: No
Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
Tell us something.: Can play several instruments at an unimpressive level. Currently most interested in whistling with a side of acoustic guitar.

Re: Comparing Killarney, Lir & Wild Irish High Ds

Post by Narzog »

whistlelaurie wrote: Fri Sep 16, 2022 11:26 am I bought a high D McNeela Wild whistle. I'm busy comparing it to my other D whistles. I like that it's a little heavier than others and I don't mind that it is black. It is fairly easy to play and has a great lower octave. I like the chaffy sound of it. The upper octave is a bit hard to be in tune on F and G and A unless you are playing fairly loudly. Those notes come out a little flat when played softly. Maybe this is typical of D whistles and is part of the "sound". My new whistle is tuned as sharp as I can physically make it go and the lower octave F, G and A are then perfectly in tune. I wish I had more leeway. However, I have run into this same issue with several of my Dixon whistles in that they are also not able to be tuned much higher than what is good for the lower octave. That said, I am liking the power and ease of playing this new whistle and the price is very reasonable.
So on the flat high notes that need to be pushed sharp. Whistles that have flat sides inside the windway dont have this, and the notes break closer to in tune even for the higher notes. I personally only like whistles like this, but many people are fine with the normal trad design and are used to them. 'flat side' whistle makers include Goldie, Burke, MK, Reyburn, Alba (which I've played all of and have easier second octave tuning), and some others I haven't played.
Post Reply